Monday, June 6, 2011

Project Runway & The Fashion Show from 11/07 on ...

Project Runway All Stars
I'm almost embarrassed to say that I've watched PR since '06! I can't stand reality shows for the most part, but was big on fashion yrs ago! So here I am, reviewing & posting to the (Prev.TV mb) site! We've survived the backstabbing remarks by fellow designers & judges & the downright injustices of winning designs! The drama w/b on for Season 17 w/ Heidi Klum, Zac Posen, & Nina Garcia! Will your fave make it to Fashion Wk to showcase their talents or will they get Heidi's "auf wiedersehen?" Alyssa M. - "AS!"

The comments framed between the "***" belong to other posters!

PR All Star Reunion: Daniel V. over Korto, Sweet P, & Chris M. - (S, J, M, & Uli)

Project Runway All Stars: - LifeTime: Mondo over Austin & Michael C.*

Project Runway All Stars2 - Lifetime: Anthony Ryan over Emilio & Uli*

Project Runway All Stars3 - Lifetime: Seth Aaron over Irina & Korto

Project Runway All Stars4 - Lifetime: Dmitry over Sonjia,* Helen, & Michelle

Project Runway All Stars5 - Lifetime: Dom over Kini and Ken

Project Runway All Stars6 - Lifetime: Anthony over Fabio & Stanley
Season 1 Winner - - - Jay over Kara Sean* and Wendy

Season 2 Winner - - - Chloe over Daniel V.* and Santino

Season 3 Winner - - - Jeffrey over Uli, Laura* & Mychael

Season 4 Winner - - - Christian over Rami and Jillian*

Season 5 Winner - - - Leanne* over Korto and Kenley

Season 6 Winner - Bravo-TV to LTime: Irina over Carol Hannah & Althea*

Season 7 Winner - Bravo-TV to LTime: Seth Aaron over Emilio* & Mila

Season 8 Winner - Bravo-TV to LTime: Gretchen over Andy & Mondo*

Season 9 Winner - Bravo-TV to LTime: Anya over Josh & Viktor*

Season 10 Winner - Lifetime: Dimitry over Fabio, Melissa, & Christopher*

Season 11 Winner - Lifetime: Michelle over Patricia & Stanley - starts @ #101 on...

Season 12 Winner - Lifetime: Dom over Alexandria, Justin, & Bradon

Season 13 Winner - Lifetime: Sean over Amanda, Kini, & Char

Season 14 Winner - Lifetime: 
Ashley over Kelly, Edmund, & Candice

Season 15 Winner - Lifetime: Erin over Roberi, Laurence, & Rik

Season 16 Winner - Lifetime: Kentaro over Ayana, Brandon, & Margarita

Iman & Isaac Mizrahi
***THE FASHION SHOW (S 1 & 2; posts below)***

The FS: (Hosted by Iman & Isaac Mizrahi)

Season 1: Anna over James-Paul & Daniella      

Season 2: Jeffery over Calvin & Dominique


  1. Season 4 Begins:

    ***Christian is weird.. Anyone else feeling this?***

    Oh Christian is definitely full of himself! Too weird; especially the hair! Gack! lol!! Steven and Rami are cool so far! They tried to kill the fat guy by running him to death! What if Chris had keeled over? The idiots!

    ***Ya thats funny. This is Project Runway not Celebrity Fit Club or The Biggest Loser. LOL! Poor big guy. He gets an A for effort.***

    No one is bringing up JACK! That face and bod was rockin' when he was getting ready for the next day! My heart rate is still up! Whoa BABY!! 8-)

    ***I could not agree more. I can't stand Macy's and I miss Marshall Fields so much. It was a Chicago institution. I went to the downtown store a couple of months ago and was aghast at what Macy's had done in such a short period of time. Marshall Fields' had class and Macy's is just crass - wait was that really rude?***

    Funny I liked Macy's when I lived in California, but it all changed around '99! I loved a lot of their suits, jackets, and slacks; Alfani, El Raphael, and Liz Claiborn! Went to shop after that, it was all "drek!" The store wasn't even kept up with clothes falling off the tables and shelves! Since moving back to Chicago, my mom says the same thing about Macy's; she wishes Fields' was there, not Macy's! I don't miss shopping downtown regardless! It gets old stepping thru construction, detours, and more (so many people)! Is the Windy City always ripping up their streets? Gack!!

    ***We didn't have a Macy's in my area, but I shopped there online and I was fine with that. Then they went and bought my beloved Famous Barr. ... Oh well, Dillard's sees me and my money way more now.***

    My son had a BF and another friend who worked at Dilliards! I only went into one in St. Louis for a visit with him! I was more a Macy's person along with outlet stores/malls in California where you could get name brand stuff at a discount; Geoffrey Beane, Van Heusen, etc! Now that I'm a big, fat pig (not too bad), I stick with a couple pairs of jeans and squeeze into my old tops! lol!! So much for that huge dress wardrobe of mines with El Raphael suits, Alfani jackets, and Liz Claiborn slacks!

    What an embarrassment! Still waiting to even care! lol! What a bunch of wierdos! "I feel terrible for saying that! I must be in a mood!" I just don't watch like I did before! Is it just me or is this DREKkkkkk?? I shouldn't say that half whacked out! I knew they wouldn't "keeeek" Christian off! I say "keeeek" since they just started an episode of Top Chef, Season 2! Weeeee kan now watch Eeelliiaa! "They just 'pppeeeekt' on Marcel so much!" It's Thanksgiving on TC2! Whhoooppeee!! Let's open those can goods and make something for the QF! Mia; you're killing me with those salads girl! lol! That was gross Elia mixing that fruit salad with your bare hands! FOAM, FOAM, Foam!!!! "Marcel!" How did Frank escape the real work for dinner with Anthony B,? He acted as if he won the QF all by himself; Mia too! Love it, love it, love it! And the adventure begins again with our Chefs cooking dinner for the judges at their disgusting apartment! Oh well, keep the Pepto handy!

    ***AHAHAHAHAHHAHAAAHA!!! Well if this is you "in a mood" well then sparkle me happy!! This is the funniest post I've read of yours. You should come on here more often when you're "in a mood."


  2. ***... I totally see Victorya as the new Chloe. I didn't care for Chloe and I think Victorya is a poor imitation. I love Chris (not Christian!) and hope he does well. I've been reading the boards for a long time and just registered. ...

    ... Victorya is more urban. But both have a good eye for shape and fit, just like Kara Saun of Season 1. I think Victorya will show at Fashion Week and if her collection is the best, it should win, Chloe or no. I think Rami will probably show also. Chris.. I hope so. Christian, I want to like him despite the bravado, but I think his taste is too limited yet. ...***

    I said it before, and I'll say it again, "WHAT A BUNCH OF WEIRDOS!" Christian is an out and out freak with the hair, going 'gaga' over Sarah JP, then totally ignoring other people's critique of his work! Talk about delusional! The other designer's crying is also so off-putting! What is wrong with these people? They cry when they meet someone, they cry when a question is asked of them about another designer, and they cry when they find out how much work they have to do! Where's the network psychiatrist? I hope someone is off-camera to help these losers! lol! That was rude and I'm sorry; NOT!!

    Victorya is good, but she isn't going to make it in my opinion! She showed about as much emotion as her dress form! There was no reaction to anything; being called on to talk about her vision or when they said she won the last challenge! I'd have more expression if someone threw a gum-wrapper on the ground! Maybe she's on medication! She just seemed dead on that runway during the judging! It's a little hard to keep up with all the players since I don't watch this season over and over again like previous seasons! These people are so bizarre, it's hard to get into it like I have in the past! The same thing happened when TRE was kicked off TC3! I lost a lot of the passion I had for the show! I can watch S1 or S2 over and over again; no problem! IT's a bit hard to watch previous seasons of PR since that judging is far from consistent! How did Jeff, Santino, or Wendy even make fashion week! They threw up something on the catwalk more than twice and survived! HOW?? Enough of my rant!

    ***Hear, hear, Jay!! I got the exact same opinion. I could have copy-and-paste the whole thing and sign my name to it, but I thought better.

    I think the Christian team should've been out - that 80s dress was awful. The problem is, this was his vision - the dress turned out just as he intended it, and it was awful. ...Christian actually thought he had a good dress. BTW, SJP's great. I think they should have her back as a guest judge.***

    Oh the outfit wasn't that bad! The problem was who it was intended! Only boney women could get away with wearing that! The everyday woman would look like Margaret Dumont in that thing! I guess I need to look again to see what the deal was with the length of the dress! I've seen shorter; remember Vincent's Blk/Wht dress "over pumped" by a backup model!

    JSP will always be "Miss SquarePegs!" Boy am I showing my age! Never really been a big fan! I never really watch SITCity, but from what I heard from 'sister critique,' she was described as a "horse-faced, potty mouth! I guess she really cusses up a storm on the show! Love Mr Big though; goes back to old Law & Order days before he became MR BIG (and not in a good way)! Must be playing the same role at home, playing a cop eating donuts all day!

    ***I think Christian is kind of sassy, smug, high strung and, um, not a favorite. Also, the designer who is hippie-ish...***

    I see him in the lite cast by Santino! Christian is a bit delusional and really needs to start listening to the critique and learn from it! I like the last dress; it was so retro, but only boney women would be able to get away wearing! I said on another string that the everyday woman would look like Margaret Dumont! That takes me back a hundred years to Marx Bro's fame!

  3. ***Go Christian... Hey where can I get some of these clothes on a budget?? (size 10...)***

    Christian wouldn't even look at you babe! He'd tell you to get your FAT Ass away from him! Size 10? Pls!! lol!! He likes 'em skinny to wear his creations! None of his stuff is ready-to-wear!

    ***Should be NO surprise on who won!! duh!! The Judges ALWAYS go for the most outrageous collections.

    Season 1- JAY
    Season 2- The judges really wanted to give it to Santino, why else was he in the final? Thank God his collection was not good.
    season 3-Jeffrey, (the biggest upset)

    This was the first finale that I didn't like. I can't believe Christian won. Talk about dated. I thought I was back in the 80s. I will watch the next season because it is fun to watch challenges. Kind of like watching the crashes in a car race.***

    They warned him all season about that retro look of the 80's! What does he do, but jump into that time machine again! Like others, I believe they chose Christian as the winner just because Victoria Beckham loved the stuff! Only an anorexic thing like her can wear it! I am sickened! Why do we watch this show? GACK!!

    ***You missed that the viewers texting/voting online picked Christian also.***

    Well something is wrong with them too! That show was PURE COSTUME designing by Christian! I'm appalled, sick, and ticked off! All those outfits made by him added 20 pounds to each model! Unless you're an "anorexic mess," you can't wear the stuff!

    ***How tall is pixie anyway?***

    4' 8"! He's still taller than Ricky! Did you see how small he was compared to his model a couple times? I thought he was standing in a hole! lol!!

    ***Jay you kill me. I totally disagree with you about Christian and YES his models are skinny and maybe he will grow out of that, but couture models always are. We know THAT whole discussion and so were the rest really.

    I had no idea Bravo was doing yet another show. I kind of wish they'd stop constantly churning out new, usually sub-par reality shows, and concentrate on improving their older and more successful ones instead.***

    I feel the same way! They keep cranking these things out and the production values are so poor! Some are so nonsensically; Skanks of OC and now NY! They need to fix TC, PR, and my other favorites SG & TD before they come back!

    ***...that braiding Heidi was raving about ... pretty sure I've seen that done before; either this season or last!
    Oh, and by the way, who else has noticed that Jillian consistently dresses like a twelve year old? Kudos to Michael Kors for spicing up his uniform with a scarf!***

    That bothered me Heidi saying that too! It has definitely been done and on her own show! IDIOT broad! lol!! Michael did it with his evening gown to determine who went to BP in S3 and I think Daniel did a basket-weaving of the corset/bodice of his dress made with plants and flowers in S2! People need to stop using definitive statements! Something has always been seen and done! You just have to "THINK!"

    I noticed that about Jillian as well! She's maybe holding onto her childhood for some reason! lol!! That denim jumper thing shouldn't be worn around her own home, much less a show she knows will be broadcast over and over again around the world!

    I thought MK looked like he was at a figure skating competition and he was bundling up for the cold! lol!! SHADES, shades, shades! Was it that bright there?

  4. ***Season 5***

    ***Now Wesley... I may need to wrestle you for that little cutie.... (and not to mention his cute little "too-young-for-grown-up-long-pants" look!)***

    We must all be child molesters to be going all out for the youngest hottie! Blaine would have been an alternative, but I really prefer people from this world! "Blow your nose baby! Lay off the COKE?" I think he's trying to be another Christian! "Not fierce, but luscious!" GACK!! Keith would be a very nice runner up! Poor Jerry! The most ego gone already! They really were slackers tonight with all those table clothes and shower curtains! Haven't they learned from past seasons? Sheesshhh!!

    ***ITA, Blaine is desperately trying to be Christian. With his catch phrases "Girlishious"?! Please... And "Holla atcha boy" He is already tired... after one episode! Now back to my new boytoy Wesley... I can just picture him in a Boy Scout Uniform (with the neckerchief & the knee socks)... HA HA HA! But of course Keith is my true favorite... *sigh* beefy, bearded, tattoos, nipple rings *sigh*.... excuse me, I have a naughty monkey that needs a spanking... BRB***

    I love it! PR producers just proved all of our points; good tv trumps talent! The last 2 challenges have had people making designs that have nothing to do with the task at hand! Those monstrosities for the Olympic challenge should have cost more than one designer and Blaine this week has to be on something more than water! Who would wear that to work even on a casual friday or quick in/out on a saturday? Shorts? Pls!! I think Tim should go over the challenge more than once just to make sure these "goobers" heard him right!

    ***My guess is Terri and Blayne; auffed. Teaming Blayne and Stella.. please! Would Keith have helped Terri if she let him? Maybe.***

    That was KARMA baby! Terry wanted to go down in flames (no pun intended) alone and she has no one to blame but herself! I can't believe she tried to put this off on Keith! I don't particularly care for the dude, but HE DID TRY! She blew him off! She was bragging about it! My mouth just went agape listening to her excuses! Kenley was horrid as well! She is so defensive! There's no shame in fighting for your design, but she's about abusive! Her indignation that Heidi had the nerve to criticize her was palpable! She had better learn to handle negative feed-back! She is a 50's drag type of girl and that outfit was all too costumey! Suede was lucky he was spared because his design was too normal! I liked it a lot though! Funny this was one of those occasions Tim Gunn was way off! He didn't like the fabric choices of Jerrell, but he wound up winning! "How can we ever trust you from now on TIM?" lol!! - OBTW, can someone get a jpg of Wesley ironing his shirt! I loved that shot of him with that bare chest! Whew!!

    *** know who Kenley is?? She's what in my college we called a "Suzie AGO" which was short in our town for the sorority Alpha Gamma Omega. The "A list" girls. All American, pretty, "pseudo-wholesome" and destined to marry the lawyers/doctors/future leaders of America. And they were PISSED if you didn't honor that talent and entitlement.

    Have you noticed that whoever disagrees with Tim and doesn't listen to his advice at the walk through, gets eliminated?***

    I just mentioned something about that earlier! Normally that is the case; people who ignore his suggestions are usually out the door! This time though, Jerrell ignored TIM and he not only survived, he won! His fabric choice was hated! Oh TIM, what happened babe?? lol!!

  5. ***...Kenley has been doing her own thing for several weeks now, not adhering to the challenges at all (which all the judges agree on) and still they kick off other real designers over her. It's ridiculous! Last season, Laura may have had a snarky attitude, but her work was impeccable. I have not been able to say the same of Kenley and her hideous patterns since day one! Its a farce of a competition, as they are basically hand picking who they want to win. ...***

    I wish I could say the judging is getting more egregious, but I've seen worse! Think back to season 3 with Keith and Bonnie! The challenge was to create a look for a dog and come up with a storyline for the woman who owns him! Keith didn't even attempt to make something for the dog, but Bonnie was auf'd because a hem wasn't sown on the model's dress! Are you freakin' kidding me? I'm still appalled by that one! There are others, but my blood pressure would just blow over!

    ***Thanks (I think) for the walk down memory lane with the reminder of that season 3 disgrace. Maybe all we can hope for is that Kenley gets caught breaking some PR rule so Tim can have the pleasure of kicking her out himself since the judges, for some unfathomable reason, seem completely unable to do it

    That's true, but enough is enough. This has been the same story for every single week now with her. And how many hideous patterned dresses should I be forced to watch in one season? Terri had an attitude as well, but her designs were much better than Kenley's. Stella's "leatha" and Blayne's "WTF-licious" creations would have been equally welcomed over that non-matching puff, mouse ears, puffed dress she made a few weeks back.


    WHY WHY WHY is Kenley still here?!?!?!?!?! Her outfit (and attitude) SUCKED. It had NOTHING to do with Hip Hop, but Suede went home? At least his outfit, although safe, related to his category. WHAT WERE THEY THINKING??? Ugh!***

    I was thinking the same as other people on the board! If you rant and rave about how talentless a designer is and that their attitude stinks, they are saved over and over again! Heaven knows I couldn't stand Jeff (S3), Christian (S4), and Santino (S2), but they all survived until FW! They had several outfits that should have cost them including the "milk-maid" design created by Jeff that should have sealed his fate just before the finale! That was the 1st time they went with 4 designers and I truly believe they wanted to ax him, but the drama was so compelling with him, they saved his ass until he finally won! Totally disgusting! I would have saved Keith(S3) 1st! At least his 'cheated' designs were HOT! That junk Santino, Jeff, and Christian slopped together "lost me!"

    ***Well it's that Kenley. God forbid... someone please take her away! They voted off Stella - the Vivianne Westwood wannabe.. now all the have to do is take care of Kenley. "Note to Kenley... Bette Page called; she wants her look back!" This season really disappoints. They are great seamstresses, but only Korto, Lee Ann and Jerell are true creative designers!

    I think Kenley is now like the comic relief in a Shakespeare play. Didn't you notice how Jerrell and Korto kept telling her "Oh yeah! That really looks hip-hop, Kenley," They could barely keep straight faces while they said it. KENLEY IS SO STUPID!! BTW, she should be locked in Cinderella's Castle for creating that Mickey Mouse Monstrosity. She probably smoked some crack and watched Fantasia before she designed it.***

    I'm glad you added Leanne! Someone knocked her for some reason! I don't like that soft personality trait of hers, but her creations have been stunning! Loved that "car fusion" challenge along with 2 piece ensemble from abstract inspiration (planter molding)! Both looked "RICH!"

  6. ***While I agree that she may have a "Personality" disorder, there's still no excuse for the way she behaves. I have Asperger's, as do my children, and a lot of people who I know, we do not behave the way Kenley does. I believe in her talent, but she needs to clean up her act irregardless of the challenges she faces.***

    I'm no expert, but Asperger's or Tourettes couldn't explain Kenley's behavior! We are now talking about someone who is EVIL and totally oblivious to other people's feelings! You can't complain about being alone when you said 2 minutes ago I'm not talking to them because this is a competition and I need to be totally focused! Pot meet kettle ok? WHAT AN IDIOT!!

    ***Evil? Give me a break. She's nowhere near as bad as some of you make her out to be.***

    I would be a little more forgiving it was just simple immaturity that explained her behavior, but like Korto said last night, "defending yourself you feel it necessary to dog me out for some reason!" What is that but evil intent? Again and again Kenley has so much contempt for Korto and other designers, it's almost palpable! Heidi didn't ask for Kenley why a 4th designer shouldn't go to FW; she just had to add that last little dig! EVIL under the RUNWAY!! lol!

    ***The reason why she dogged Korto (not that I agree - but in 'her' mind) when Korto said the other two designers were better designers and then better PEOPLE. Kenley saw that as a direct attack on her. She knew Korto was implying that she was not a good person. While she may be very immature, she understands when she's being attacked (even though she doesn't understand WHY she deserved the attack - and even if she has a 'personality' disorder she did in my humble eyes).

    So when she had the chance, (as Korto was the last person to 'attack' her (even though Kenley deserved it)) she went with Jerell and Leanne. So I don't understand Korto's anger, considering that she .. and the other designers did the same thing to Kenley. If anything Korto should have expected this, and kept her mouth shut instead of playing the innocent victim (in order to gain more points with Leanne and Jerrell).***

    It was the same thing with Season 2; Santino, Daniel, and Kara thought they should go to FW leaving Chloe behind! Funny after all that betrayal she won the season! It was so strange they went on that attack with Chloe since Santino was on the "outs" with all of them! He had pushed Kara to love that crappy jumpsuit in the last challenge and the others compared notes and wondered why it was unfinished being one piece! Chloe had created 3 pieces for Nick! It just doesn't make sense to even ask that question! It's there to provoke and nothing else can explain it! Totally serial especially from Daniel who loved Chloe!

    ***The Chloe issue wasn't based on her personality. It was based on the fact that she already had a successful business and didn't seem to need the win as much as the others. She was also very laid back, and there were some doubts as to whether she really had the "hunger."

    Not like Kenley's case at all, where it's a matter of an alienating, thoroughly unpleasant personality at work. Geez! Kenley even makes Wendy Pepper look good in comparison.***

    I totally agree, but I was referring to asking that stupid question of the designers! Why don't they bring mothers out and have them choose between their children! That's about as lame! It's their job to choose wisely, assessing the work of the designers, but instead of making a reasonable choice, they put it back on the competitors, then fall flat with that cop-out of taking all 4; for a minute anyway! I HATE THESE PEOPLE! lol!! Poor Chris (S4) really thought he had a chance! It was all for show bringing him back for half a show last season!

  7. ***Korto wuz robbed. Leanne and her petals? Even Kenley had more interesting pieces although I felt her collection ran out of steam. ...Was pretty disappointed with this season and then to have Leanne and her petals win took some of the air out of my sails for Runway. Thank goodness it aired the same night as the final debate so that I got to sleep thinking of Obama's success instead of Project Runway's failure.***

    Like I've said a while back, I'm not a fan of this season or any of the finalist! For the most part they phoned it in; especially Korto's maid-of-honor dress! I like Leanne's collection; it had cohesion, it had a point of view, and I loved those petals! You just don't see things like that! It was original, feminine, and something women can and would wear! It would be better if you're pencil thin, but that pastel green top was stunning with the layers! Jerell dropped the ball in the end, Korto's collection wasn't polished enough, and Kenley is stuck in the past! All of them had pieces to like at FW, but Leanne won this season hands down!

    ***I agree with you completely. I think that Leanne was original and put together shapes that haven't been seen on the runway before. However, Korto's designs and shapes--although extremely lovely to look out--were all things the judges had seen in some form or fashion.

    I just re-watched the finale...and I must not have looked very hard at Leanne's evening gown the first time. It is exquisite. It is a beautiful color, perfectly crafted, and flowed like a dream on the runway. If there's a question whether or not Leanne can do anything but petals...the answer is "yes", just look at that dress!!***

    I'm still trying to figure out what was wrong with Laura's collection in Season 3! Like Koors said, "it looked rich!" It was glamorous and well crafted evening wear! Her clothes made Jeffrey's look like off a "seconds" or defect rack! I'd have put Uli in front of Sebilia as well even though all season she created the same summer dress every challenge! Michael's outfits looked a little cheap and I can understand why he went down in flames! Jeffrey; NOPE!

    ***Wow, I completely agree with you on this one!***

    If I have to play a doctor, I'd guess the poor thing needs to go to a sleep diagnostic clinic to be tested! Without a doubt Chris March of season 4 shows all the symptoms I started having; the weight gain, uncontrolled sleep periods, the snoring! You are amazingly tired and weak from "Sleep Apnea!" Mines bordered on Narcolepsy, so I needed to take naps even if it meant to pull off the rode for 15 min.! I just hope he hasn't hit the ground a couple times as I have! It's a wonder I haven't cracked my skull open! Waking up once, a small tv rested near my head! That was a close one! He needs a c-pap machine ASAP! "I'll make the appointment BABE!"

  8. *****THE FASHION SHOW*****

    ***The fact that they need to subtitle Merlin irks me. It's not that he has such a heavy accent it's that he is so heavily affected. I didn't like his line about "bitches rule the world."***

    Oh he's a character! Had my 1st experience with Merlin last year from "Janice Dickinson's Modeling Agency" from Oxygen! He was a client looking for models and they had to practically agree to cart wheels to make him happy! What a weirdo! I liked that James-Paul won! I said I wasn't going to get involved with this "knockoff" and here I am! Oh well; the formula works!

    ***So Merlin knows how to play the reality show game? Well, he's a hoot and he knows it. I'm not going to hold it against him. James-Paul is cute and has talent to make something classy and edgy that upstaged every designer on the show. He's an early fave for sure.

    OMG, thank you, Jay!!! So, that's where I remember Merlin from!! I love JDMA, and now I can totally recall Merlin and his borderline officious walkway micromanagement. The guy was a complete loony. I thought the walks he wanted them to accomplish were ridiculous and even backbreakingly painful looking, like he expected them to walk while being circus contortionists at the same time. And he was so offensively self absorbed, it was really off putting. Ugh!!!

    ...The people on this show are people they plucked off the street and put them n a 24 hour sewing class to be on the show. It was truly terrible. What is the deal with this why no Project Runway? ...***

    No offense, but you obviously didn't watch the show! These guys are professionals! They've done shows before and have created their own lines! I mentioned earlier that Merlin appeared on "Janice Dickinson Modeling Agency" last year and he hired several models to contort down the runway! He was weird back even then! The show's not great, but it'll do for now as a replacement for PR which has gone to Lifetime! It's already been taped and will start telecast maybe in August!

    ***So far there has not been one single piece on this show that wouldn't be laughed off the stage on Project Runway....***

    I think there have been several outfits that could measure up especially with the limited time and resources of these contestants! I thought both outfits from last week were great with just $40 to complete the design! The pleated skirt for the luncheon and the rock concert outfit in black which won were very HOT! I think we tend to forget about some of the horrendous outfits that went down the catwalk on PR including Dracula capes, ripped pieces of fabric attached to a dress, and Kenley's mermaid costume for the flower/nature challenge! Some have been just as appalling as some of the FS creations!

  9. Poor Keith; I knew he was "toast" when he got the most normal of the models and thought this would be an easy challenge! Famous last words on all these reality shows! lol!! Reco and Daniella are obviously the best designers, but they go at it was different directions! Reco is full of confidence, finishes quickly, and knows he'll be in the final! Daniella is good, but has little confidence and even when she produces a great outfit and actually wins with it, she has nothing but doubts! Too sad for her!

    I wonder why Daniella didn't select Merlin for elimination! It was a perfect set up since his creation was a disaster! Angel's dress was a disaster and probably should have cost her! Poor Keith! Another hottie gone; that's 3 in a row! Lucky Reco "ain't" cute! lol!! "Watch it James-Paul!"

    ***Ha! So you also see James-Paul is cute.. Well, he is a bit of a fashion elitist isn't he? How dare real women interfere with his "art.". Ah well, he has time to learn.***

    I've said this before and you're making me say this again, many of these designers are professionals! They've had shows, hired models, and have businesses already! I mentioned Merlin was featured on "Janice Dickinson's Modeling Agency!" How soon we forget the oddballs, freaks, and weirdos that have been on PR along the way! Remember "rock n roller" Stella, "Tanning Bed" Blayne, & 50's retro-con Kenley? Many were limited, stuck in a time warp, or couldn't construct their designs! Some didn't deserve to be there much less make the finals like Rami, Santino, Wendy, and even Christian who won! They beat these people over the head all season long with what they were creating, but then they walk away with fame, fortune, and even some winning a final! What a bunch of losers! It happens! It'll happen again!

    This happens every season! Wendy made it while Austin was dumped at the last minute in S1! Santino skated thru on S2 with some horrid designs! How did Rami and Christian make it to the final in S4? Finally in S5, what was up with Kenley making it while sending Jerell home? Shocking! Reco gone! I thought Anna would be in trouble since it wasn't a real collection! I have no idea what she's talking about "navy" running thru everything! Hmmm! "I saw prints babe!" I thought James Paul might get tossed for being too innovative! Oh well, we'll have to deal with 'Miss Smirk' for another week! Pls GAWD, get Daniella! lol!!

  10. ***But what about Project Runway's Michael Knight? He bombed in the last evening gown challenge with some purple shirred stripper number....***

    I remembered it and thought the same thing! The difference is having Michael didn't kick anyone off! This was one of those times all 4 designers got to show off their wares! Laura's stuff was something else! It looked "rich!" All 4 were seen on this show, but they ended up hosing us all by giving us this BS that only 3 of the 4 can actually be judged and voted on! IDIOTS!

    ***I agree. If they don't trust America's taste, they shouldn't have sold this show as "America votes".All Americans Bravo! All. But I still want James-Paul or Anna to win.***

    I'll ask you "did you watch the same show I did?" lol! Reco was in the top or given a lot of praise when in the bottom of the group! He was in trouble only once and that was with the "Halston" challenge! If he had been kicked off I wouldn't have been as upset! He saw the original and totally went in his own direction with a corset design! Reco should have been in the final even with all the trouble he had with the wedding gown! I really thought Anna would be in trouble because her stuff was "too off the rack!" This is a design show! She pretty much regurgitated her season on this one show! lol!! I just didn't see this "navy" she said ran thru the collection! Maybe if I watch the show for a 3rd or 4th time I'll see it!

    ***Reco was eliminated based on the judges' evaluation of his final collection not on his track record throughout the competition. A comparison of his past work with that of James Paul would not serve any useful purpose.***

    Either criteria doesn't work for me! Fine, ignore everything Reco did, he still should have made the final 3! I love Anna's work, but it really seemed regurgitated with her admitting she brought along bits and pieces of the entire season to her collection! It's not like any one is 'not entitled' to be there! I think James-Paul is probably the most talented, but maybe a little young and doesn't edit! He tries to put absolutely everything into each piece he creates! Daniella is ok, but that "skinny" thing is really bothering me! There are some designers out there that are probably successful dealing with only thin women, but for the contest, she shouldn't be able to get away with that! It was one reason Christian wasn't as deserving to me! His stuff is for 'rail thin' girls he can "slip spoon" into the "crap" he pinches together! Even Sarah Jessica Parker nailed him for his outfit being too "snug!" Now we have his illegitimate sister doing the same thing! Let's hope Reco is one of those people that becomes "bigger" not winning this show!

  11. ****Project Runway - Season 6 - Lifetime Network***

    Believe me Tim has been wrong many times before! Remember that Zodiac challenge in Season 5? Jerell had this costume long-plaid skirt outfit and Tim panned it, but eventually he was named the winner! I understand where he was coming from and I was shocked as well, but it happens; Tim can blow it too! I'm more shocked by his cattiness a few challenges ago when Johnny was caught making a lame excuse why he started over from scratch! When Tim slammed his offering he made up some story of "steam" stains or damage! As poor Johnny is leaving with his tail between his legs, Mr. Cool Hand Luke GUNN, exclaimed he couldn't believe Johnny was using that excuse! That's right babe, kick a kid while he's already down!

    ***Could we please get a gay male designer on this show who can represent a strong gay man? Jeez - Louise gets eliminated, but it's CHRISTOPHER up there in tears. C'mon, Queens - Grow a pair!!!***

    That was weak! They were just critiquing his work and "the river was flowing!" Did I hear cold-hearted Heidi call out "NO?" The judges really need to reign in their insults! It stopped being about the clothes when they go on these personal attacks like "what were you thinking? Oh the problem is he/she wasn't thinking!" lol!! Koors is fast gone from witty, past snarky, to just about disgusting! I love how he says something "low" then hunches his shoulders like "it had to be said!" No it doesn't MISS KITTY!

    ***I too am disappointed in Gordana's auf'n, but Heidi has no taste and wants the drama between Althea and Irina for ratings. ...***

    Gordana was doomed if you remember the script! If a designer has a life-altering experience in their latest creation, they are guaranteed to be auf'd! In S3, Jeffrey seemed to have that feeling with that "milk-maid" outfit, but they saved him for some reason! Along with them wanting the young guns to compete in the final, Gordana was just giving off such a negative vibe! She looked stressed, the shoulders were schlumped, and her aura just said "I'm an old lady!" I think she might have done very well, but you have to exude some confidence! You need to do more to defend your design than trying to tug at the "heart strings" of these judges; they don't have any hearts!

  12. Thank GAWD this is finale's week and the season will be over! Tim Gunn is getting on people's nerves; including mines! The man was almost frantic a moment ago since so many of the models weren't ready to go on! He's supposed to be the calm effect master! What's up with him these days? This is the 1st final with 3 women right? They are really behind schedule! Carol Hannah was sick with stress I'm guessing, but overall the others are being a bit cavalier! "Find some urgency ladies!"

    Fix, setup! lol! Why do they beat up and rip apart the eventual winner? They know darn well they are behind a person all the way, but try to make us feel they will be auf'd! I hate this show! Irina takes it! The villain wins again! They said from the time of creation, you need some color! She does a complete black line and she wins! They congratulate Carol Hannah for incorporating color so well into her line, but then she's out 1st! These people are too weird!

    I really liked the repeat of the reunion show! It was great seeing some of the old favorites! Luckily the ego-maniacs who were so over-rated were weeded out early; Santino & Jeff are the ones that come to mind 1st w/ Uli and Michael! The final 4 were great choices and brought a tear to my eyes to see the judges appreciation of Chris and Sweet P! It came down to the 2 designers who are the most confident, but have a point of view you want to see and root for; Daniel V & Korto! Korto could be a little more gracious when she doesn't win! "They gave you all due credit for your growth!"

  13. ****Project Runway - Season 7 - Lifetime Network***

    Jesus just wasn't ready and had to go! Tim warned him about that hideous seam due to his extending that brown, leather dress into a longer gown! His vision couldn't be denied; in his eyes only! He just wasn't going to get any better! He's just stubborn! He reminds me of Santino! He knows what's what, but for his own creations, he follows other rules! He should be brought back to help with construction detail for the final 3, but it probably won't get down to his period of elimination!

    ***Anthony is one of the most fun designers you've had.***

    Must be the "southern charm!" Anthony doesn't take things so seriously! Some of these designers remind me of some of the "drag queens" on "RuPaul's Drag Race!" The ones taking things too seriously are getting hammered by the judges while the fun-loving, easy going types are moving through without much of a problem! Judges have actual used the term "we don't need anymore 'serious' drag queens!" lol! The designers have to loosen up; Emilio, Jay. Amy and Mila! You see Jesus who was much too serious is long gone! I don't keep up enough with the names to come with the other serious characters! I need to go back and look at that chart on one of the earlier pages!

    ***I'm pretty sure this is the most pissed off I've been with the outcome of an EC! Not only did Emilio not make anything, he stood there and waxed thoughtful and innovative about why!***

    I'm sure the majority of us are shocked by that last EC, but I'm not sure why! It was obvious that they wanted to save Emilio! He was given a "mulligan" and Jesse was the sacrificial lamb you had to know was coming! He built up some "cache" w/ the judges b/c of the quality of his work! They are giving him a break from this loony challenge! I was shocked that they would pan Anthony as much as they did! They weren't going to get rid of him so they could have found better time spent criticizing someone else for their choices! Too weird to say you made a garment too realistic and soft! So bizarre! He soften the material and so it wasn't "hardware" anymore? IDIOTS!

  14. It's hard to like many of these designers! What is up with Emilio playing musical chairs with the models? He picks Holly as his model again and again, and while looking at her the entire time chooses someone else! He just crushed the poor girl! Mila seems to have a problem with everyone except Maya, and poor Amy who started out so hot, just spiraled into "bizarro world!" What happened to her? Love Jay's little shorts! We need to go back to those old trashier days for guys! Why only girls get to show off skin?

    ***About Emilio changing models, I think towards the end of the competition, some designers panic and look for any perceived advantage. ...Mila and Maya and even Jay are also serious competition. I don't know what has happened to Amy except that she has the need to be experimental/innovative so that she veers from elegance one challenge to arts'n crafts messes the next. ...the designers haven't inspired any strong opinions. How many times can I verbally ogle Seth? Why no short shorts for guys? Well besides the fact that my knees look much better covered, I remember when short shorts would just be asking to get beat up.***

    Sorry, tattoos, nail polish, and being straight are big turn-offs for me! lol! I don't mind being used, but let it be a real boy or man! lol! I hate desecrations of the body and skin! Anything more than a couple earrings is blasphemous in my book! Something subtle I can live with but PA's, bolts thru things, and facial/neck art of any kind is not acceptable! That's probably what put me off Season 3's winner Jeff above and beyond him being talentless and a jerk! Don't get me wrong, I'm sure he had a few things even I liked, but no way should he have even made the final after that "milk-maid" costume came floating down the catwalk to qualify! It was horrible and he should have been escorted out of the building then and there; along with his model if she really thought that thing was sexy, romantic, blah, blah, blah! I'm still infuriated by that BS!

    Ranting on, what was worse than Jerrel in Season 5 being auf'd after winning the challenge to make the final? My mouth still hangs open with that one especially letting Kenley show a line when she also should have been auf'd long before the final! There were some shady dealings going on behind the scenes! I just don't know how Heidi, Michael, and Nina can rationalize some of their decisions! No doubt Emilio has some great talent, "he's a legend in his own mind," but he should have been auf'd with the "string-bikini thing!" Hey he BS'd his way past the judges; they bought it and he's still there! That 'one-trick pony' Mila should be next! She reminds me of "Miss RocknRoll" Vanessa from a couple seasons ago! Everything was black, leather, and edgy! "Old lady, ya need a little more to come up with to create a full line!"

    As for the "shorts" situation, I did put up with some stares and "cat-calls" from cars, but that was my style! I was draggin' 80's shorts and spandex into the 90s! I didn't look my age, so I wasn't going to dress like an old man! I had the goods, and I showed them; often! lol! I'm shocked to go through old boxes to see shorts I wouldn't get past my knees now! Hard to believe I was a 28" waist a 100 years ago! The material couldn't produce a good 2 handkerchief! How shocking! lol!!

  15. Like RuPaul might joke on his show, "send all these bitches home!" I'm not thrilled with any of them! Emilio's ego is out of control, Anthony's taste level just isn't there, that was a freakin' costime Seth Aaron produced, and Mila's just a bitter, old crone! Every time she pans someone elses' efforts, hers comes into question while they get praise! Jay is good, but he's not as good as SA and Emilio! Overall my choices would have been SA, Emilio, & Jay! I guess they had to add Mila; season 4 repeat! Who will really make it btw J & M??

    ***JAY was robbed.***

    I agree! I thought the judges would come to their senses since it seemed they went ape-shit over his armoured leggin's; they were hot! Didn't they actually say Mila's collection was a bit edgy, but at the same time stuck in the 60's? I only watched it once; SORRY! I'm pretty sure they complimented Jay on his innovation and cutting edge presentation (futuristic), but they obviously don't trust him to have a complete, cohesive collection! They went what was safe like Wendy in S1 over Austin and Rami (rouch King) over Chris in S4! They just never warmed up to either until after it was too late and they were stuck with what they chose! It's the usual hypocritical thing you have to deal with in life! People say one thing, then change the rules & expectations well thru the process and revert back! You see it all the time! Total BS!

    I remember on RuPaul's Drag Race in the early episodes, she manipulated some of the elimination! Mystique got a "get out of jail free card" in the 1st episodes and continued to win in group challenges, but the rules were changed! In episode 3, every one was up for elimination and I think it was specifically keyed to "auf" Mystique even though the bitch was on the winning team for the commercial; "...Extra Greasy Shortening!" Hate the finalist, but what can you do? Being a "backstabbing Bitch" is sometimes rewarded! Go JuJuBee!

    The usual happens with designs that I think are kind of tacky and costume-like; they're the ones that are chosen as the winning collection (not line)! More BS to digest from Nina and Michael! Mila gave what Mila gives; it was ok, but no real surprise or show piece was there! The judges just raved and she wound up in 3rd as I thought she would! Then there's "Mr Ego," Emilio who developed a "line" that could go right into stores! I knew he was doomed! He was writing off the show! He had signature textiles already produced! He could move on without even talking to PR producers the day after he got the check! lol!

    Finally we have the winner, Seth Aaron! OMG, where do I begin? He so reminds me of the odd designers from past seasons like Jeffery, Christian, or Jay; stupid hair, weird clothes, tattoos, nail polish! They're their own person I guess and that helps in the judges saying "they are cutting edge and should win!" I've hated those decisions ever since! The only one I picked to win and she did was Leanne! The rest were a complete surprise! Hell the finalist chosen were even more so!

    Looking back Santino had clothes falling off his models and he still went to Fashion Week with that gold pallet monstrosity! Poor Kara; she really blew it! Same with Wendy over Austin! I knew her stuff was going to be doughty; what else could you get from some rural old lady? "No offense Wendy!"

  16. ***I think Chis March is the most beloved contestant of all the years I have watched. So it is nice to see good things happening for him! Those designs for Meryl Streep for Golden Globes and Oscars' were great:

    What amazed me the most about chris was that he stayed awake long enough to design a killer outfit! LOL I loved how on Runway he would be found sleeping while the others were running around like crazy! Kudo's, Chris!***

    We talked about that years ago! The poor thing has to be suffering from "sleep apnea" & narcolepsy like me! There's just not a lot you can do! Most don't want or have the money for the operation to clear up a deviated septum, and others can't stand wearing that mask attached to c-pap machine used to help push air down your throat while asleep! FOr those who don't know what I'm talking about, you stop breathing in your sleep! I sometimes do it awake; take one last deep breath, then holding it until I start gasping for air! It's not a lot of fun, but I still use it or I wouldn't be here typing now! Chris should have that looked at! You wind up having very high blood pressure, there's a chemical imbalance with the lack of sleep and you put on weight even if you aren't eating like a beast! I stabilized, but there's still a lot of emotional turmoil & lethargy! Sleep is very important, but I'm seeing more and more people who are having trouble! ALl my life I settled for 4-5 hours since it was so uncomfortable! It finally caught up with me in my 40's and I couldn't ignore it anymore! (No pun intended), but "wake up Chris and have that checked out!"

    ***Actually that was the first thing I thought of when they kept showing him sleeping! I really would hate to hear someday that he has passed because of this! Hopefully he will read this and your post.

    Chris suffers from both sleep apnea and diabetes. In fact, his diabetes medication is partially responsible for his frequent napping.***

  17. ***I think Kenley just like being disagreeable in S4. She was so inflexible. Gretchen and Kenley remind me of each other because they are both so annoying. Loved Chris March--the hair--not so much. He was definitely an "outside the box" designer. ...Isn't Aaron known as Big Daddy? I see his show every Sunday on FN. ..***

    How Kenley survived to the final is anyone's guess in season 4! That "fish-fin" dress for the flower challenge should have cooked her fate! Chris was definitely more innovative! I loved how he was vindicated in the all-star reunion show a couple years ago! The huge ego-maniacs (Santino, Jeffery, & Uli) were dismissed right away and I loved seeing the growth of Sweet P! I just wish Korto would stop playing the victim! She's good, but she "ain't" that good! lol!! Daniel a good choice!

    Aaron from FN wasn't a bad choice for that season, but it's hard to jump to true stardom just because you won that show! I've seen his show a couple times after he won, but sunday mornings are reserved for "political chat" and sports! I don't need to watch Big Daddy since I won't ever be making any of his fare!

    On other shows like Hell's Kitchen or Top Chef, winning guarantees nothing! Daniel from Season 2 Pr. Rwy may be successful, but I almost never hear or see him! The industry is so big, why would established designers welcome more saturation of talent? lol!! If not for RuPaul, Santino may have dropped into obscurity; why didn't that happen? GAWD save us!

    That challenge was one of the reasons I wasn't that unhappy when Emilio lost! He wasn't humbled at all by that "hardware challenge!" He knew he dodged a bullet, but it didn't make him think, "wow, I was so lucky!" He continued to talk shit! If I remember correctly he was saved while a past 2X winner, Anthony went home! Emilio was a much better designer, but he blew that one and he "had to be saved thru production!" He was also a snake when it came to the models! He rewarded that very professional model by selecting someone else the next challenge! A real "scummer" designer there! I think PR could rationalize that Anthony had been brought back after being eliminated, but even though Jessica Alba requested to wear his dress, they figured it was time for him to go!

    ***...Yea, Emilio wasn't cool with the models. Tim says in an interview that they'll be showing more of him; says it sometimes takes 4-6 hrs. for the Q&A of the designers? Can you imagine?? No wonder they get so stressed out!***

    Yeah, deliberation goes on for hours and I knew they were editing the life out of the creative process of these challenges! The same thing goes on with Top Chef! Supposedly the judges can dissect the hell out of these dishes and I find it a little disturbed! lol! Either it's good or it isn't! If you want to go all the way down to saying, "I hate black pepper and I'm going to punish him for using it," that a little disturbed! One of the judges on "Chopped" is like that; just loses it over something like black pepper! I put it on everything savory; that and garlic powder! It's a habit! I think I just want that feeling of sprinkling something since I don't use salt unless absolutely nec. to cook with! Salt on meat is nec.; tasteless if cooked w/o! I've tried!

  18. I knew it! You could see this train wreck a mile away! The so called geniuses and winners of challenges are going to crash and burn! They've bitten off more than they can chew and Gretchen is going to be the catalyst of the explosion after the runway! You are going to find these guys throw each other under the bus; it's a sure thing! Gretchen took over this team and her hand is on every design! I can't wait for this!

    I haven't laughed so hard in ages! It was so obvious Karma was going to rain down on Gretchen's team! They were so full of themselves, putting down the efforts of the other team, and they are now trying to figure out how to survive this hit to their egos; JUDGEMENT IS AROUND THE CORNER!

    Justice was served! Gretchen & Ivy showed their true colors! You had to know all blame would be shifted around to Michael C.! That was such a phony pact they made to go down as a team! The bus was just getting warmed up before Gretchen in the end thought that individual work should count when deciding who should go or not! It was priceless! I was almost ready to fall on the floor laughing; I couldn't breathe! You knew it was coming! The topper was Tim just blasting the whole team for letting Gretchen bully them into this position! It was PRICELESS!

    The whole team aspect was a joke from the beginning with "Team Lux!" You saw how fast they reverted and pushed each other under the bus when it came down to elimination! My GAWD, Gretchen & Ivy showed their true colors! I wonder how they can look each other in the eye after that scene on the runway during judgement! I LMMFAO! It was hilarious! Gretchen's plea truly should have won her at least a "Razzy" if not an "Oscar!"

    ***At the end the models were hemming the clothes. What kind of designers ask a model, their model to do something that they should do? If they had no qualms with telling the judges that time was spent on "helping the weak link Michael C," then they should have no problem telling the judges the models hemmed their clothing.***

    How soon we forget S2, "The Garden" challenge! The eventual winner Chloe was gluing individual leaves to her dress and I'm pretty sure the model helped out in the end! In S4, the "Hershey Choc." challenge, Jillian had a lot of help from her model getting her outfit finished including using needle and thread! A lot of that probably goes on, but was edited out before! With the "Super-size" episodes, they can leave in those little tidbits!

  19. ***Group challenge collections; yay or nay? - I think it was designed to elicit the drama it got. teams of 6 with no leader - you're asking for "the bully" to come to the fore.***

    Well as soon as you got the gist of the challenge, you knew who would bull-doze the project! There was no doubt even if they mentioned something about "no team leader," she was going to take over and her imprint would be all over the place! I mentioned it last night! The team with so called 'talent' with multiple winners of challenges would "go down in flames!" History shows over-confidence will "bite you" in the ass before they even knew it! That collaboration in deciding the direction of the project didn't fool me! Gretchen had not so silently taken the lead and admitted her hand was in each design! That was a recipe for disaster and I've never laughed so hard seeing these people throw each other under the bus at the end; team resolution or no! It was hilarious! The back-peddling and excuses were flying! Gretchen: "May I have my Emmy now? Ya gotta admit I was the lead!"

    ***They have a sweater called the GRANDPA SWEATER!***

    You knew they were doomed when you heard the design ideas! As soon as I heard "Grandpa sweater," it was a done deal! These people were going to go down in flames! Every people was hideous, ill-fitting, and boring! There was nothing you could take and say, "I can work with that!" Tim was so right to "lay into" Team LUX!

    ***The "team challenge" is an Intense episode ...but so VILE! ***

    It was unfortunate, but A.J. had to go spending all that time on "one, hideous" shirt/dress! The poor thing must have no clue how to really sew! - I promise you, Gretchen has learned nothing! She'll still have that ego and doesn't think she did anything wrong during that team challenge; including judgement, back-peddling, and totally throwing her team under the bus! It was a horrible performance all around! They should all be ashamed! Michael C. could have just reason to turn his back on all of them!

    - - - -

    ***Yeah, it was kind of obvious, from her last vicious comment about AJ to the camera, that Gretchen's still very much on her own planet. But Tim's little speech was directed at the other designers, at least some of whom will realize he's right. It was just an added bonus that Gretchen was right there to hear that Tim was totally onto her. It will be really interesting to see what happens to the dynamic in the workroom over the next few episodes.***

    - - - - (Project Runway)

  20. ***...And the ever-widening gap between Tim's opinion and the judges?***

    Tell me about it! Remember season 5 with the "Zodiac" challenge? Jerell's creation was being panned by Tim and he won it all! The other designers liked it and the judges agreed or they wouldn't have gone along with the choice! Tim was right about last night though! He knew "Team LUX" was up a creek! lol!! He warned them before the runway!

    - - Extended Judgement of Team Lux: - -

    ***Gretchen really takes the cake - No one will ever come close to the sheer evilness that was Wendy Pepper.***

    But Wendy was no designer! We can hate Gretchen, but she has won 2 challenges! She's full of herself and needed a little deflating, but if you check her out, back to normal already! Relief washed over her! I think she knew that one piece of A.J. would cost him no matter how much Heidi may have wanted to sacrifice her! Listening to all the drama about S5's Kenley, I wondered why they put up with it? It wasn't like her stuff was revolutionary! That hideous octopus flower # should have cost her a spot! Now we hear how disruptive she was with laughing inappropriately and talking over other people's critiques! What is the criteria for keeping some of these losers?

    ***Agreed. The real funny thing is that she thinks her game is on point; that she's so slick. The judges and Tim are on that ass.

    ***I wasn't aware that octogenarian 1980's chic was back in style. Gosh, the Team Luxe collection was awful. Gretchen isn't very nice at all. I know you have to play the game sometimes to end up winning the game, but I think it might bite her butt in the end.***

    It's amazing she has the nerve to be shocked she was called out for trashing the team like that! All of them should be ashamed; esp. for the attack on Michael C.! My Gawd, they even signed that unholy pact to go down as a team! That lasted for about 2 min.! lol!! I've never laughed so hard at someone like Gretchen, just backpedaling and scapegoating Michael with the blessing of the rest of the team! Michael selected these guys if you remember! They not only threw him under the bus, they back up and ran over him again! Looking at the previews, he's out for revenge! Looks ugly!

    Just watched the end a couple more times! It doesn't get any less hilarious! Kors just lambasted them for throwing Michael C. under the bus! "Wretchen" will have to delude herself into another reality to live down this performance! If I were her friends, what would I say? OMG; the humiliation! Knowing her, she's already dosed them with her version and will explain it all away with "editing!" Where have I heard that before?

  21. ***I haven't liked this woman since she first opened her mouth. She's manipulative, and forces her opinions to such an extent that some of the weak-minded contestants rally around her like Nazis with Hitler. I actually believe that when she started the discussion about whether or not they should name someone, she actually wanted them all to agree to say "Michael," but then saw the way the wind was blowing. ...***

    "Wretchen" was already working people's nerves by the "party store" challenge!
    She'll probably make it thru like Kenley even though she's a pest! At least Gretch does have some kind of aesthetic the judges like! To this day, I'm wondering how Kenley from S5 made it all the way to the final! She was an absolutely horrible person from all accounts! Tim said the editing was "kind" to her! lol! What a disturbed "puppy!"

    ***I don't like her at all either. She's made snide remarks about Michael on more than one episode. She must have some lame axe to grind.***

    They all did! lol! My GAWD, Michael selected them and they pretty much stabbed him multiple times like the bad guy on "Murder On The Orient Express!" They all took their turn; TWICE! IVY had the nerve to add "lazy or ignorant!" How do people forget that? Michael's eyes almost popped out of his head! He didn't even defend himself! That's what made it even more pathetic of Wretchen and Ivy; they pummelled the boy! No apology forthcoming! Even A.J. only commented that someone's feelings may have been hurt! Feelings? That was a "blood bath!"

    ***Revenge or hype in those previews for next week? Will Michael C. try to get even with those designers?***

    Guys; it'll be their own paranoia that is in evidence next week! There has to be a lot of guilt with what they did as a so called "team!" They not only threw Michael "under the bus," he was being scapegoated from the beginning! It had already begun during fabrication of the designs! "Wretchen's" antennae were raised and concocted that fake "Pact" only to drop it when she saw how it was failing!

    This reminds me of a "Roseanne" episode where she played a hideous practical joke on a neighbor that didn't even like her! The neighbor ignored the whole thing and moved on, but for the rest of the episode Roseanne was paranoid that she was going to be "pranked" back! It wasn't happening and her mind was working overtime trying to figure out what was coming next! I think the designers are creating this "vengeance" in their heads; even though justified! I'm most shocked by Christopher & Andy! A.j. saw what was happening and pulled back a little at the end, but overall this was the worst behavior I've seen out of a team in all the years I've watched! They were holding hands and hugging moments before and during the judging of the runway for Gawd-sake! Just goes to prove, designing "ain't" easy and you just never know until you see it on display!

  22. This was the most excruciating "team" runway to date; even when Andrae from season 2 went on forever with his "life story!" What did he do; over 10 mins of talking, crying, and going back and forth? "Wretchen" took it to an all new level "back-peddling" like no other in history! Ivy's little chirping voice invoking "a baby" and how much she thought the collection was beautiful was too much as well! OMG, the nausea can't be described!

    ***Should have let Michael C. do his own thing instead of forcing everyone to make "Grandpa sweaters?" Why was everyone agreeing to Gretchen's ideas? Not to mention, they totally ignored what Michael C. had to say, even though it was probably better than Gretchen's ugliness.***

    These people were scatter-brained from the start! During judging, you had them talking about re-enforcing strengths and hiding weaknesses, but how often were Wretchen, Ivy, & Christopher complaining about Michael C.'s ineptitude? If he was having trouble with the cowl for instance, why not have someone else do it rather than having him experiment? It was horrible btw! They were all guilty!


    This happens every time; here and on Top Chef! Over-confidence is a real killer and Karma just settles in in situations like these! Wretchen was so sure they would clean up and it was the "hardest" fall I've seen of a team since Season 1 on Top Chef! Steven was so sure his team was "fly!" He was in total denial to the last! Even when being kicked out the door in the next challenge for the wedding, he was grumbling and thought everyone was "hosing" him! Super egos are a dangerous thing in some people!

    ***Tim was talking to the team...what would have happened if he had told Gretchen directly, in private that she was being manipulative? NOTHING! Why? B/c of exactly what she said at the end - "I don't think I'm manipulative." You can't help people like that - they can't see it, and therefore they can't change.***

    I don't know how to tell you, but "Wretchen" is one of those truly delusional people you can't tell anything to! They have things set in their feeble little minds and nothing you can say will change them! It will take an act of GAWD believe me for this girl to see the error of her ways! She still doesn't think she did anything wrong! To the last she's making excuses even though in her mind she's the best designer! "If that's the case, why do you need to shoot people down as much as you do?" It's just so low-rent! I don't even talk to people who comment on every person that walks by! That would be a "Wretchen!" That's going to be a moniker for people like her from now on; "a wretchen!"

    ***Rather than 'wretch-en', I think I prefer 'retch-en'. Wretch, while being despicable and vile shows her attitude, retch is more the reaction she generates in the vast majority of this board!***

  23. I wish I knew how all of them from Team LUXE couldn't see they were going down in flames? The worse was really how they all turned on Michael; actually making up excuses that they took too long out of their busy schedules to teach him how to sew! If he's so bad, how did he win a challenge; had immunity (HELLO)? How can they work together ever again? I wonder will Michael C. really go after them; Andy, Wretchen, Ivy, & Christopher? Poor Christopher & Andy; been tarred with the same brush as the true instigators of evil, Wretch & Iv! The one person that comes to mind that delusional was Santino (S3)! He could have a garment falling apart and he thinks it's genius and anyone to criticize it is out of their minds! You saw how he attacked Nina back then! I wish I knew how in world he made it to the final! His stuff was so crappy!

    ***So what was up with the whole Michael C. + Ivy thing?***

    If it isn't paranoia, I think she's just making excuses for not being on top! She wasn't getting many buttons if any and she just needed a way to explain that away! She had to have seen all those buttons Michael C had gotten and she was seething; no doubt along with Wretchen! lol!!

    ***I hate Michael C - I am by no means a designer and I don't have the eye for details like the designers do, but the way they keep harping about his lack of skills in sewing and construction makes me wonder.***

    Hate is just plain ridiculous! It isn't rational! He has done nothing! You have bitchy attitudes by Andy, Wretchen, Ivy, now Mondo from next week's preview! What is wrong with these people? Jealousy is an awful thing! MC's win and immunity is just plain Karma for me! I pull for the underdog; as most people do!

    ***What a bunch of classless people. I don't get why they've all become bitches. What exactly did Michael C. do to deserve their hatred? Can't they at least be gracious losers? He's not even an annoying winner, which I could see pissing them off. He's being so professional about it all. It makes me like him more.***

    Add Mondo to the classless side of the ledger! THe previews show he's quite upset with Michael C winning! Wow! Are all these people going to wind up bitter, angry people? My GAWD! These people need help! - MC's dress after they panned it, just made his win all that more sweet when he see this show! I love it! Justice! Karma!

  24. Well for me this episode couldn't have unfolded any better! Michael C. went about his business and didn't go out of his way to get even with any of his "rotten" team mates from last week! It's obvious there's tons of animus, but it appears to be more guilt than anything! People like Ivy, Wretchen, Andy, & Christopher have to think about what they had done to MC! They can't look him in the eyes esp. after they made that fake pact to not turn on one another! I can still hear Wretchen saying "that's not my style!" What style would that be? lol! Class shouldn't come into the equation either! These people are really working themselves up into a frenzy actually trying to turn other designers against MC! Even April is starting to nod in agreement! Since Ivy didn't get very many buttons, I truly believe she made up that rumour to explain away her lack of admirers! Like MC could tell others not to give her their vote; what is she insane?

    After getting crushed last week, Wretchen didn't pull back! She can't keep her criticism to herself and just couldn't believe Michael C was getting all that praise! She and IVY were so sure MC was in the bottom! It just "broke there faces" that he actually won! Karma! Justice! Let's see what happens next week! From the preview it looks as if Mondo has jumped on the bandwagon just "hating" on MC! I suppose they just can't help themselves! So very sad for them all! They are really looking bad! I can't wait for the reunion show so they can all be called out!

    Last week's judging had me gasping for air I was laughing so hard! As they're throwing Michael C "under the bus," Heidi kept trying to focus them back on "these five here!" They tried to pummel the guy and Heidi really stepped it up on them! It's usually quite cruel, but these guys deserved it! The real killer is, none of them have been humbled in the least! If anything, it looks as if it will get worse! The previews show Mondo snapped at MC and on the runway during judging, it appears he was sacrificed again! lol! I can't wait to see it! The reunion show should also be a "must see" because this will be "FEATURED!" Have you ever seen such bitter, evil intended people! I watched the video blogs from the designers and it got no better! Of course HIvy spent the majority of her 2 mins cracking the design and lack of talent of Michael C! Peach spent most of her promoting Mondo's design saying he should have won! Andy beat up MC a little more and pretty much blames the judges! He just doesn't understand! "Well idiot, that's why you're there; to learn! Moron! Hard to believe I really liked this guy! I thought he was cool, but he's just as bitter as the rest of these "people!"

    You had some others that were truly lame! Peach had to go! She's not a designer! She's more a seamstress than someone who creates! Sorry! April's was hideous! Michael D was in a no win situation really! His model and that dress were huge! What are you gonna do, make her some shorts and t and be done with it! I'm at a loss what he could have done! He's lucky that Peach's was even worse and they felt he had something else to express! Peach just wasn't going to create something that original!

  25. ***Gretchen's attitude in the last challenge... - Ivy's immature and I doubt she will be one of the top 3 in the final challenge. This past ep, she was upset b/c Michael won again. Oh well, it's a competition and she already won 2 challenges in a row herself.***

    Wretchen was thought to be the best; sorta like Irina in S5! She was a bitch and was always looking over her shoulder, criticizing others, even suggesting she was being copied, but Wretchen has taken it to a new level! Since she's been falling on her arse of late, she's been a little touchy; esp w/ MC winning those 2 challenges! I'm just shocked Michael D. has jumped on the "let's hate MC bandwagon!" Why would he call MC an idiot when he's trying to clear up this rumour thing with HIvy?

    I can watch that runway from last week over and over! It may have been just how they edited it with the quick glances, but I loved the reaction shots! MC eyes almost bugged out of his head when his so called team began "throwing him under the bus!" HIVy's "I don't know if it's laziness or ignorance" was hilarious! No one has ever attacked another designer like that on the runway! What could she have possibly been thinking! And instead of being ashamed of herself, she persists in airing every bit of discomfort she has with MC existence! When he won this last challenge, you could hear her say "of course you did!" It was like she was saying, what else can happen to us? "Well you could have been eliminated, but the old lady bit the bullet for ya!"

    I watched it again, taped it so I could watch it again! I never stop laughing! It was all there; Tim warned them ahead of time that they were in trouble compared to the other team, you had total chaos with all 6 models doing their work! They still weren't done btw! Supposedly A.J. still hadn't finished the collar of his shirt-dress so that was why "the ascot!" After the runway, Heidi starts calling out names and HIvy knew they were in trouble; "OMG!" She knew!

    From there they have to go back and figure out where to go with impeding doom; hence that fake pact! I believe you have that kind of dialogue with the judges and the losing team all the time, but theirs was so hilarious with the back peddling, they had to super-size the show! Just watching these people go down in flames just tickles me to death! It was all too perfect! The only thing that could make it even more entertaining was to see Michael C win after they "threw him under the bus!"

    No wonder the ratings are up! I just want to know how Wretchen and HIvy can go back to their lives and rationalize their behavior! I'm sure the usual "editing made me look like a bitch" excuse will be prevalent! I can't wait to see the next vblogs to see these people dig a deeper and bigger hole for themselves each week! They are truly struggling with this dynamic of some guy they hate and a lack of appreciation for their work they think they deserve!

  26. ***Did Gretchen not watch this show before she auditioned? Seriously.. - This collection really doesn't look like any of our work and I think that's a Project Runway first!" Why would you be proud and think it's a good thing that 6 designers didn't stay true to who they are?***

    Thinking of that moment, you could see a strange look that came over her face when she said it! She knows it sounded bizarre as it left her lips! I understand where Team Luxe was going, but it's hard to believe that up to the last they thought they were ok! The delusion went further with them attacking the aesthetic of the other team when it was obviously HOT! Those pants that Casanova produced made the line! He didn't really change that blouse after Tim had panned it! Notice in Mondo's vblog, he wasn't happy about Casanova as the winner because of his "Diva moment!" He must have really stressed his team until he turned out those slacks! A.J. had to go; one horrible shirt/dress produced! That's the only thing that saved Wretchen since she was truly in charge and directed them down this awful path of 70's design; "a grandpa sweater?" lol!!

    ***April should have been in the top 3 instead of Christopher***

    Am I missing something? April's dress was nice; SAFE! There was no wow factor! I appreciated she kept an element of the old dress in the new design! I don't think she should transform or deconstruct so much it isn't even recognizable! Loved Casanova's look, but my GAWD, where was the old dress? Andy's was dyed into a new reality! One of the best makeover's I've seen was with Season 2's winner Chloe! She took someone's blue jacket and turned it into the hippest little dress; totally taking it apart and used pretty much only those materials with some new piping and trim! It was gorgeous and you could see where it came from!

    Going back and looking at the vBlogs on Lifetime, the other designers were complaining about the construction of Michael's C's garment! It had a 'wow factor' and it probably helped that it was black! With the runway lighting Nina and the rest may have missed something! I doubt it; they're usually right on you for the least little thing! If a thread is hanging off a hem they let you know! How bad could it have been for them to vote him the winner? Some might think this was planned and made into a big thing due to drama with MC and the rest of the designers! Who knows; who cares?

    I lost a little sympathy for poor A.J. after seeing the designer dish on myLifetime! OMG he was so easily led by Gretchen! He was so delusional following her lead; no matter how "crazy-town" the direction! It's great theatre! Can't wait for next week!

  27. Over the years, few designers are that cutting edge in their own style! The real Top DESIGNERS in the world look like freaks or weirdos; ie. Donatella V.! Have you seen some of those characters on Rachel Zoe? They are at their peak and so many are wearing costumes and wigs looking like they're from another planet! In the past the best costume designer for the movie industry was Edith Head! She looked like a city librarian to the day she died! I'm offended when I see these people at a fashion event looking as if they're homeless! That stupid skull cap on Emilio S., lopsided off his head w/ dirty boots and army jacket at FW last season really bothered me! The whole world is watching, you're supposed to be an authority in fashion, but you look like you don't know how to dress yourself! Too bizarre; ya know what I mean?

    ***I remember getting into a heated debate with someone about this very thing. ...while the crazy and dowdy dressers were the most creative and impressive. The designers that are making the money don't HAVE to care how they look. Their creative energy goes into their designs and businesses. They can get fat, get old, be orange, or wear a garbage bag and still remain at the top of the food chain.

    Has Ivy surpassed Gretchen as this season's villain?***

    Phony HIvy went right to Michael D to hug him after she survived elimination! I would have told her to take a flying.....! She really "raked" him over the coals for no reason! It was her design! If she's unhappy with the end product, she should have been a classier person and go the route Mondo took! I'm so impressed by him in so many ways now! He realized he had been a jerk and unfair and fessed up to it! Who else has done something that magnanimous? Not in this lifetime!

    How far down the food chain did they go to hide who won the season? I'm hearing Ivy, Gretchen, Andy, Mondo, Christopher, and others! In the past I think going to #4 would do the trick starting with the fake collection of Austin Scarlet in season 1! What are they dropping down to the 7th eliminated designer? lol! It's over so for them to keep it under-wraps with all the blabber-mouths around is impressive!

    ***I just feel like Michael C. is nowhere near the worst on the show NOW or this whole season. They talk so much shit about him not being able to sew... but others there had stuff that was AWFUL and nobody ever called them out or acted so upset when they were safe and still "IN." ...***

    I can watch the "DISH" video clips on myLifetime over and over again! These fake people are just too hilarious! When Michael C went on and on about how much the judges liked his recreation of that bridesmaid dress, they just couldn't contain their envy! As soon as the door closed behind him as he goes off to the runway, I think it must have been Andy who exploded, "whooooo....!" They all lost it! It was so funny! MC says "I won," ...and HIvy had to come back with "of course you did!" lol! She was beside herself in more ways than one with her sister in hate Wretchen! If frowns could freeze, those would have been priceless!

  28. ***Gretchen + Ivy - I don't know - how much can editing make up? Last week, when Michael won, & those 2 bitches sat there w/pusses on their faces, it was SO immature.

    Michael: "I won!"
    Ivy: "Of course you did."
    Gretchen: FROWN

    I mean come on, say congrats to the guy, even if you're a self centered ass that thinks your design was better. Can anyone say SORE LOSERS?***

    The real killer is that when "Wretchen" won that 1st challenge, Michael C was the 1st to hug and congratulate her! It's like the most popular kid can't deal with others taking on their own glory with these broads! This was the most "painful" runway and judging I've ever seen! The Team Challenge will haunt all of them for a while! That phony pact stating they would go down as a group fell thru real quick! I love how Team Luxe tried to get MC to give up his immunity; or am I crazy? I know they must! They turned on Michael like a pack of wild dogs! I've just never seen anything like this! The assault of Marcel on Top Chef is the only thing comparable! I'm still horrified by the back-peddling, then the total viciousness of these guys when they all contributed to that disaster they called a collection! At least A.J. didn't stomp him with both feet at the end! He knew he was lost making only one bad piece! Just a horrid result!

    I can watch this episode w/ Team Luxe every day; well the runway and judging anyway! Wretchen's team was so sure they had this one "in the bag!" I knew Karma would have a surprise for them! When Heidi started calling out the names of "Team Military Lace,: HIvy knew it and said "OMG!" Love the fake pact they proposed while waiting for the execution! That without a doubt was the most painful runway judging with members back-peddling from their designs and one being thrown "under the bus!" I just can't wait for the reunion show! How will they all justify their behavior towards Michael C? It was just disgusting! I just wish I could hear them try to answer to family and friends; "hon, why were you such a bitch?"

    Well I hope they do better for the finale; Val, Chris, MD? That would be scraping the barrel as far as I'm concerned! Not too impressed with anyone, but Val, Chris, MD? Hmmm! I have no vote for anyone; even the Diva's; Wretchen, HIvy, & Andy! Karma would have MC, Mondo, & April! MC for being bullied, Mondo for being redeemed, and April since she's so bored with the whole thing! "Hell yeah; GOOD JOB!" lol! She reminds me of Darlene on Rozanne! All she needs to do is dye the hair black! PR had another designer several seasons ago that was good, would win a challenge, then about fall asleep with appreciation over her win! lol! I think she was on season 4, Asian girl, thin, and totally dead inside; maybe Gloria or Valerie! Made a horrible trench coat for a challenge! Maybe out of seat covers; who knows! That's too far back for me to remember! She's was a lot like HIvy in that she thought she was the best and others would copy her work! Not sure really!

  29. Andy was lucky Michael D's construction skills were poor! Either could have gone home! He certainly did deserve to be laughed at if he thought Jackie O would be seen in those "cargo's;" Please! I'd love them for myself, but come on...!

    ***How can Andy still be in the competition? How can ANYONE make pants that go so deep in your butt? ...Andy should be out. I think he was saved by the fact he got made fun of ...They keep saying how bad MC is, yet they don't turn out anything worth praising. - I liked Michael D as eye candy and his humor. Oh well, at least I can still look at Christopher.

    You're not alone at all wanting MC; I think he's absolutely adorable and he just seems like such a nice guy. Of course, some of the attraction may be me wanting to take care of him after he got so horribly attacked by his evil teammates weeks ago.***

    I'll take the other woman for my collection; Michael Drummond! I like a little meat, but excessive hair is gross; sorry! Who likes flossing with hair? The beard is a problem though, but those eyes and lips...; ugghhh! I wonder is he going bald at 31? He's always wearing something on his head; cap or doo-rag! OBTW, Mondo was just an adorable little pixie last night! lol! Must be the "child molester" in me! He looked like he was about 12 in those shorts, cumberbun, knee-socks, and suspenders!! - Chris is much too boring! He went right along with the in-crowd berating MD on the runway when they promised not to turn into a pack of wild dogs! So much for that pact in that team challenge; "no that's not my style!" Yeah, right!

    ***Recap Ep.8: Top: Mondo (declared the clear winner), Ivy, and Christopher

    - - - - - - - - - - - - Bottom: Valerie, Andy, and Michael D (went home)

    'Every time Tim says there's a twist... I wanna smack him in the head!'***

    I don't know why these idiots are surprised each time! The shows only been on for years! Top Chef does the same thing; always a "so called" twist! It always means more work; that's all! Get over it!

    ***... and of course the finale won't be any different: The moment Tim says: "You will have to create a 13th look for the runway," jaws will drop and the final 3 will utter: "I did NOT see that coming. AT ALL!"***

  30. ***These designers don't have much of a backbone towards Gretchen...***

    I know it might sound odd, but I know it can be the case for successful men; Gretchen's height! Tall people command a lot of awe and respect without even opening their mouths! If you look at the team challenge, #6, Michael C. and the rest of them are so short compared to her! MC was actually looking up at her with tears when she was pleading their case during judging! All of them must be easily intimidated by this tall, big-mouthed woman! After all that's happened, they still listen! She walks around the room critiquing the other designers like she worked for the show! She really is worried about other people's designs entirely too much! That may be why she's been losing of late! "Deal with your own work lady!"

    ***Lifetime vs Bravo-TV - I think Lifetime needs to be more clever and creative with the challenges, and plan things out better.***

    It seems as if they think all they have to do is put a time limit on each challenge to make it worthwhile! Grinding these people down to create something in less than 24 hours just makes no sense to me since they're there for so long! Why not give them more time to do a project and cut out some of the leisure time since it's unproductive anyway? From what I'm hearing they're just drinking to excess and hanging out with no tv, newspapers, and magazines! I guess they should feel fortunate they can speak to loved ones! Some shows like one of those "fat shows" uses a phone call "as a carrot" for some performances! Seems as if production is squashing creativity, not promoting it!

    That "bridesmaid redesign challenge" choice could have gone either way! I think Mondo's design was more versatile, but Michael C's design was "rich!" It looked really sharp and hot to me! What made it more satisfying a win for MC was just watching the envy of the other designers that said he can't design, sew, or even work hard! Why are they being so judgemental when they are the ones falling on their faces?

    I looked at the team challenge again and the delusions were rampant! There you have A.J. talking about the egos of the other team and that his team was so cooperative, blah, blah, blah! My mouth just hung open; then I laughed of course! These people were so sure they would take that challenge, but even HIvy saw the writing on the wall when Heidi started calling out the names of Team Lace/Military! That runway and judging can be replayed over and over! It's so painful to watch Wretchen peddle back on her efforts; "...grandma had arrive... saving a crappy collection!" OMG, even A.J.'s mouth went agape after that one! lol! Those 2 challenges and the drama behind the scenes were priceless! The rest has been a huge snooze! Maybe when we get to "stolen fabric...," things will pick up!

  31. I like both Chris and Michael D.a little, but Chris proved to be a silly follower in that team challenge! I'll take MD, but need to see that hair line! My Gawd, did he wear that cap and bandanna while he slept? The show didn't get real interesting until the team challenge where the drama began! That episode and the follow-up with the maid of honor redesign challenge (#7), I can watch those 2 every day! It was hilarious with the back-peddling from Team Luxe's line to throwing Michael C under the bus! I pick up something new each time I see it! I had no idea A.J. was still proud of his team and castigated Team Lace/Military as being "ego-driven while they stayed a team!" Talk about delusional! lol! Even Wretchen lost it saying "none of this looks like any of us! That's a PR 1st!" Huh?

    Funny you mentioning Laura! Her collection proved true creativity can turn $8,000 into a $100,000 line! I don't need a "hag," but I just thought she was fabulous! Always dressed to the "nines!" She was well put together, confident, obviously intelligent! Most designers pale in comparison, but there have been some nice shows other than season 3! Love LuAnne's petals in season 5, but most winners are producing costumes making it original and new! Irina was ok, but her attitude stunk in season 6! Emilio probably should have won last season! THE usual BS was used to justify giving it to Seth Aaron! OMG, those clowns clothes can go right to the circus as far as I was concerned! I guess I'm stuck in the past! The thing is I would have worn the stuff back in my 20's! Unfortunately that was back in the late 70's & 80's! Reminds me of shopping in Fiorucci here in Chicago at Water Tower Place! Again we're talk about the late 70's! I guess I should go back and look again! I just wasn't happy with the decision! I couldn't stand Emilio, but I liked his collection! They called it a LINE! What a crock!

    ***Now Michael's getting it from the judges too... - He was clearly only in the bottom b/c there needed to be 3 people. He got more compliments than complaints. Guest judge: "You worked well with the fabric. I like the cocktail dress." Kors: "The clothes are constructed well, sewn well, and tailored well." He went overboard with the train. So what? He should have been safe.***

    I like that Michael is hanging in there; keeping up with the popular kids! His feedback was about as good as you get being in the bottom! Thinking of comment made by Wretchen and A.J., "I think this is a PR 1st!" Who else got such glowing praise in the bottom like that? They really liked his effort! That'll keep the other guys in check; well maybe!

    ***Ivy in the bottom again***

    Well she had made it further than she should! The judges kept commenting on her vast talent, blah, blah, blah, but I just wasn't seeing it! She used muted tones with creations with little, real design! She went over the top tonite making a costume for a kid's school play! The waves crashing,.....! Michael has been a lot more versatile and I'm sure she'll look back and wonder how that happened!

  32. ***Fewer good designers this season***

    I think they've been struggling for talent from the beginning! They had better seasons than others, but from Season 1 with Wendy; what can be said? Season 3 & 4 were loaded! I liked Season 5, but Leanne still a weak winner! Her stuff was gorgeous, but can she do more than petals? Season 6 & 7 had some good designers, but it amazes me to find some that have no clue even about sewing! How did they get on the show? Creativity is truly lacking and so many creations are just reworked from the past; nothing more! How many different ways can you work the "little black dress?"

    ***ANDY is THE designer to beat this season... even Wret-chen knew that from the beginning! Besides, every designer this season has been in the bottom at least once. Even MONDO, whom I greatly respect, has made one or two clunkers.***

    But their creations weren't necessarily made poorly! Andy made obvious mistakes in taste as well as craftsmanship! Mondo's resort wear was still complete and wearable! Andy has been struggling all season! His lone win should have gotten an honorable mention to his fellow designers who helped him up to the last moment to glue those ribbons to the dress! I think I lean away from the guy due to his own insecurities! Jumping on the bandwagon with Wretchen and Hivy in attacking Michael C didn't sit well with me! Mondo redeemed himself a couple challenges later and they are best friends! The cool crowd is still shutting him out! That ain't cool! They're all under the same roof! You can't act so fake in one instance only to scream and talk later about how something is driving you insane!

    ***...OK, I don't mean for this to sound insensitive at all, BUT...I really thought April deserved to win over Mondo. I feel like the judges almost felt obligated to give Mondo the win b/c he opened up about being HIV positive.***

    Typical, if you say something isn't meant to be insensitive, you KNOW it's gonna be insensitive; you sprayed it anyway! I wondered how long it would take for someone to blame "pity" on Mondo getting that last challenge win! It doesn't matter that he won the previous 2 before you even found out his health status! What else can be said? Take a look in the mirror babe and make your statement again!

    As for April winning, she got her charity win with that negligee w/ the granny panties for the red carpet! Come on! lol! I wear more to bed! "Get off THE BLACK TOO!" The girl is morose; pret' ne'r catatonic at times! She barely smiled when she did win that challenge! I think people talking in their sleep are more animated! Pretty girl, but she would drag me down; the dead pan voice alone!

  33. ***Ivy or Kenley? - Who do you think is the worst villain? I for awhile thought Kenley couldn't be beat, but Ivy has these delusions of grandeur, as well as the queen bee bully mentality. On the one hand, Kenley threw a cat at her man....***

    Agreed! Kenley was just delusional and a little psychotic! Hivy is a liar, a conniving drama queen, & had little remorse for what she was doing upon being busted! "That's your opinion" she would say! Like Wretchen, they just can't take criticism! Listening would be admission that the criticism was justified and correct! Talk about delusional! Mondo took that "critical" energy and continued on to create some lovely designs!

    The problem really centered around those 2; HIvy and Wretchen! Without them it might have been a nicer season! The others like Chris, Michael D., and Valerie were just followers! When they said something unkind, it was mostly parroting the evil twins! April's in a category all her own! She would depress me to no end! She's no saint, but she isn't a villain either!

    ***As someone who lives in Western Canada (AB if you care), the first thing when I saw Andy's design was LULULEMON! That company is huge here, and among yoga fetishists across North America I think. They're known for their fabulous sports athletic and yoga wear. Who knows if he copied it... but they sure look really similar. Both the logo, and the style of clothing the logo adorned.***

    I just wish since Andy's getting every benefit of the doubt, why can't the same benefit bestowed onto Michael? HIvy went around poisoning the air with the other designers! Mondo thought she was out of it, A.J. came around slowly enjoying his time with MC, then Wretchen came over giving some kind of condolence! I'm sure it fell on deaf ears! lol! Why would anyone believe anything that woman says? She's about as pathetic as HIvy!

    ***...These people make Santino look like Mother Teresa, yet they don't even have a 3rd of his talent! Week end and week out he came up with the goods and knocked it out of the park!***

    You must be joking about Santino! "Knocking it out of the park?" When was this; the Paris Hilton challenge that was in his head all the time (him and Nick)? He was in the bottom so much, I was shocked Heidi allowed him to make the final! Even towards the end, his garments were falling apart, loud, & very costumey! He was horrible! IT was a big "come down" for him, Jeffery, & Uli when they were auf'd off that "PR All Star Reunion!" Michael probably wasn't surprised he missed out on more praise for his work! I loved that Chris March made it along with Daniel V., Korto, & Sweet P! They need to do that again sometime!

  34. ***What are you talking about? Michael has gotten more special attention and leeway than anyone else this season!!***

    You call being called a cheater, berated by shrewish, hateful women, & in general disrespected "special attention" and leeway? SEEK HELP; get back on the meds! Come on! Leeway indeed!

    ***How do you even know MIchael isn't a cheater? And if he did indeed use sticky tape, it is cheating. Someone needs to learn the difference between right and wrong. You are CLEARLY bias, and stuck up Michael's bum.***

    Forgive me for saying this, but "you are an idiot!" You just admitted you don't know; so you'd rather err on the side of assuming he's guilty of cheating! Life in this country isn't like that babe! Ya want to go to Russia where you have to prove your innocence, be my guest? I'll admit I don't know, but I'm not going to listen to the irrational rantings of these bitter women! They're just throwing out supposition with nothing to back it up! Michael asked HIvy what he did and all she could say was he cheated! She couldn't come up with anything directly like he sabotaged her design! It's all "pie in the sky" BS and you jumped on the bandwagon with the other idiots; Michael D, Chris, Andy, A.J., & April! These people like to think they are so strong and independent! Ha; I don't think so! They went right along with the "hatin'" on Michael C with no justification that I can see or you can relate right now! This begun with HIvy and Wretchen and it won't end until they're gone! You see how bitter HIvy still is and who can believe anything Wretchen said to MC in consolation? Well? Hit me with your best shot!

    ***If you wrap enough double sided tape around a model then you could get by without fitting a model at all. I'm not sure that it was fair for Michael C to blame his model's bust inserts, though I suppose a model might collude with a designer to save an ill fitting garment so that she would go further in her own competition. Has the quote about someone leaving the show been placed yet?***

    A drama attached to the "cheat card" was played by HIvy! To this day she still thinks Michael C cheated! She never came up with anything factually it seems until this thing about packaging of tape found in the ladies' bath! HELLO; was Michael C going tranny or something? That should have told her if anything, only a model or other female designer could have used it! Does she think the model followed some nefarious plan by MC or that he knew she had done it on her own? It pretty much was dropped after it came to the attention of Tim! He brought them all over to discuss it and pretty much shut HIvy down saying the cameras didn't pick up anything and in general it was too late; SO DROP IT! She really looked like a fool bringing this stuff up showing how bitter and envious she truly has been all this time when it comes to Michael C! - As for "leaving the show," it was one of the models! Mondo's model had been eliminated, but since someone else dropped out, she returned as someone else's model now! Maybe he'll get her back before the season ends!

  35. ***Mondo was acting like a little bitch. Heidi was just giving her opinion on the designs which she has a right to do since it is her line. But several of the contestants were being rude to Heidi not just Mondo.***

    It's a rare occasion for Heidi to come to the work room! No one has ever liked it though! They can barely tolerate Tim nosing around! For her to make those criticisms, which were valid, will always fall on deaf ears at 1st! You would have to recognize in 5 sec. that you just wasted hours on a design that won't make it! The thing with Mondo's neckline was valid right off! This particular time he should have seen it was fair! Heidi couldn't get the thing over her head without mussing her hair and makeup! Women tend to fix those things 1st before getting dressed! You have to be able to get it over the head more easily!

    ***Michael's dress was amazing...but nothing new. I also didn't see the Statue of Liberty in it. that being said, I thought that it was well made and better than both Gretchen's and April's. - ...but as the dress that gets you to the show, I'm surprised at all the praise it got.***

    In comparison to Wretchen and April, he deserved the praise! He's getting beat up on his choices every challenge and he's going to make it! Karma baby! The judges were raving about Michael! I guess HIvy's head didn't completely explode listening to all that praise! She's still alive and kicking somewhere! lol! I remember when MC won the "maid of honor/redo," she just looked sideways at Michael just not believing how much the judges loved his dress! The envy and animus was absolutely dripping from her pores! Same with Wretchen! It gets to be the last episode she's now "Mother Teresa" until that stupid comment about everyone getting a 2nd chance! "Babe, you were the only charity case! Andy, Mondo, and most of all Michael earned it and beat you down to the bottom!"

    ***A flowing black dress like that does not show well on tv. I'm sure it would of looked better in person. Yes, the slit was too high, but that is easily fixed. The back was VERY well down. And MC really did make use of whatever the fabric was b/c it flowed perfectly. I saw the Statue of Liberty in it ...The thing with Michael is the he has known to change his mind at the late minute.. or even make more than one dress and STILL have it be decent or even a winning one.***

    I think that's what may be "bothering" the other designers! MC is so unsure, makes backup designs, then comes thru in the end! That normally doesn't work! Every time someone over thinks these challenges or is unsure, they go down in flames! Even when MC has been in the bottom, it was still better than most and he was in little danger of being auf'd! That must drive some of them insane! lol! HIvy may be under a doctor's care by now seeing him win that last challenge! The judges were just raving! I'm so surprised Wretchen was able to contain herself; even with that loser outfit she produced!

  36. ***I like April more than Gretchen, and think she has more potential. I wish April hadn't jumped on the "hate wagon" like the others, b/c that really turned me off of her. I agree that she should have realized she was making the same look over and over, but it's too bad the judges never said anything to her until now. Tim tried to warn her at Mood, but she apparently didn't listen.***

    I thought they both should have been eliminated for obvious reason! Wretchen did have the worst attitude for someone that hit the bottom so many times! April really had been warned; she just wasn't listening! I don't know what else could have been done except maybe Heidi or Nina should have said something after her last black outfit won a challenge! "We do expect to see more!" After her bratty behavior to Michael, I wasn't that disappointed! With Wretchen, fine, show that Bohemian junk; it won't win for you! It's between Mondo and Andy now!

    Thoughts on Designers Voting on One Another for FW - It's usually no big deal, but the results wound up being so different in the end! All the other designers voted for Mondo (of course), but the rest was fascinating! For one thing, even though Michael won the last challenge, he only got one vote; Mondo's! April may have gotten the next highest approval for going to FW and she wound up being "auf'd!" Andy was a shoe-in while Wretchen truly is in last place; she got a pity vote from April! The judges obviously didn't care so why do they put the question to them? Probably to start up some drama; who knows? Any thoughts on it?

    The designers haven't been that memorable! If they are, it's normally b/c they're ego-maniacal jerks; Santino, Jeffrey, Christian, Irina, Wretchen, HIvy!

    ***Haha, that's so true! Normal people are hard to remember.

    Personally I like Michael C's see-through garments better than Gretchen's panty/booty short garments.***

    Regardless of what we think, the judges loved it! I just wish HIvy had been there to see it! They would have been ripping him a new one; just as Wretchen I suppose (idiot or idiot savant)! April even joked a couple weeks ago how many times they've "panned" Michael's work only to see him win! When will people learn; take things as they come! Don't assume anything and definitely don't say something is "a snap;" you're normally done then! This season so far has really worked out for the most part! Each of the finalist had multiple wins! It wasn't like they threw a bone to one designer to justify them being there! I even think April should have been the one to go! Wretchen has a wide range and took chances; April never did! They were relatively all the same and she should be embarrassed; she was warned by TIM! "Give them some color!" She really cut her own throat! She possible could have made it if she had used that blue for the entire dress rather than just an accent in the front! Poor April! "You had your chance!"

  37. ***...if anything that blog made me dislike April even more. She got booted b/c she sent the same damn thing down the runway week after week, not b/c they wanted to play the drama card with Michael C. ***

    She's not a credible source regardless! I thought she was going to give me some insight into why she hated Michael and give a lame reason why he just made them look bad! lol! I scanned the whole thing; it was all self serving and just a chronicle of how she saw the challenges went! I was bored; oh well!

    ***When will people learn you just make yourself look bad when you decide to talk smack about people on a public forum? It's possible Michael was that way, but that post did nothing to shed light on his supposed behavior. All April accomplished was making herself look like a douche-bag.***

    She was about as informative as HIvy when she was brought back to help the remaining designers! Michael asked her what he did to her and she really didn't specify how he did that! It was like "you sabotaged me and that's all I'm going to say about it!" Yeah right; we all saw her go on and on and on! Tim had to come forth and slay the dragon! The empty tape spools were lame and totally 'BS!'

    ***The judges hated just about every thing! Well who did they seem to hate the most?***

    Everything was so "hate-able!" This was one of the worst final challenge runways in a while; maybe of all time! They were all holding back it seems; left in the work room! I was very disappointed; it's like they all need another month to prepare! Maybe it's just me! From Tim's visit to Andy, it was obvious everything was rushed at the last moment! The major problem with most was the styling! Anybody? - Michael eliminated? This is BS and I may not even watch the runway show next week! This was another horrible finish! I hate this show! lol!

    I watch the show, but not to the extent I'm accustomed! The 2 or 3 challenges in the middle of the season are the only ones I watch over and over; the "team" challenge where Michael was tossed under the bus, then redemption in the redesign of "maid of honor" challenge! Like last year, I won't be waiting with baited breath the finale; it's anticlimactic! The other 2 designers just don't measure up to Mondo! If someone else wins, I think that would be a stretch even for Heidi, Michael, & Nina; even with Jessica Simpson! Last season is still throwing me for a loop though; same with season 3! A lot of the stuff was so costumey; made for skinny girls only! They say a show is supposed to take you to another level, then you edit down for the average woman! Those circus clothes from Seth Aaron just didn't impress me! Neither did Jeffery Sebelia's! We haven't heard from Jay at all from season 1; even on the red carpet! I've heard and seen many of the people who weren't even in the running! Chris March is huge; in more ways than one! He designed 2 dresses for Meryl Streep! What do the winners of this "joke show" really do after the selection besides disappear?

  38. ***I remember one of the past winners, Jay maybe, was supposed to design a dress for Heidi to wear to a red carpet event. As I recall he designed it, but she didn't like it after it was done and she wore something from another designer. It would be interesting to find out if anyone kept track of the careers of the previous PR top 3 to track which ones do the best post winning.***

    That adventure with Heidi was chronicled in Jay's 4 part special after the season! He went to all the trouble of getting the dress done and Heidi changed her mind! That part happened, but most people don't realize, she did that without even seeing what Jay had created! It was a good choice, but she didn't know that at the time!

    ***WTF; Gretchen took it over Mondo and Andy? I am so dropping this show.***

    Well I'm done as well! At least Iman and Michael will keep me entertained back on Bravo with "The Fashion Show" next month! I could have lived with Andy, but Wretchen was the last one I thought could win with those "off the rack" creations! I've never been so bored! Both Andy and Wretch were so monotoned and dead to me! Not like I was into Mondo's aesthetic with the patterns and hard edges, but he's a lot more creative than anyone else this season! I'm just appalled and I'm glad they've run me off! Just one more lousy show I can "X" off my list! Thanks!

    It seemed like Nina and Michael were fighting to make sure it was Wretchen! I thought they were about to break out the boxing gloves! This was a violent choice out of all that I've seen! I go all the way back to season 1 and this one has shocked me the most; only because she shouldn't have even been in the final! What a gyp! Oh well, on to The Fashion Show! This season stunk except for the drama with Michael! The reunion really didn't hit it as much as I hoped! That stunk too! Oh well!

    ***It's called Project RUNWAY, not "OFF THE RACK!"

    Someone already mentioned the "Hell's Kitchen" formula; boy, girl, boy, girl! Mondo was too reminiscent of Seth Aaron maybe! Wretchen's stuff is "off the rack" for the most part, but Nina and Michael were fighting for her like no other in the past! Heidi was truly over-ruled this year! Jessica wasn't enough of a help to secure victory for Mondo! Not like she could have wedged her large hips into that plaid #; "forget about it tubby!"

  39. How many PR winners really do anything though? The runner-ups and even the earlier eliminated seem to do better overall! You may never hear from Wretchen again! Who knows!

    ***I agree. She may surprise us by insisting all of her outfits are produced ethically and manufactured in the U.S. Somehow, I am skeptical as that is usually a death sentence to the career of an aspiring fashion designer.***

    Mondo will probably end up being more successful NOT winning PR! I wouldn't sweat it if I were him! He's had the exposure and I've heard of his exploits outside of the show; so who cares? I'm over it! I was ready to drop this joke of a show for a while now! I just thought I'd give them one more chance after what happened last season with Sosa! He's still shocked! lol!

    No justice, no Karma, no nothing! Some seasons you can re-watch; this finale, not a chance! The only thing that kept me coming back was to see HIvy and Wretchen get what's coming to them! They not only got off "scott-free," Wretchen wins and HIvy is given a complete pass! People actually came to Wretchen's defense; why? She's still a bitch whether she agrees or not; and FAKE as April said! That was shocking; April's bitter pill! Where'd that come from? All the girls heaped on her before the guys, even Michael came to her aid! What a rotten ending! At least I can cut this show loose and pick up the pieces with "The Fashion Show" next month!

    ***April and Ivy were fine with Gretchen when they were all working together on the show, but once April and Ivy got home and were able to watch the tape and see what Gretchen would say behind everyone's backs, they quickly changed their opinions.

    Did Nina make a jab at Seth Aaron?***

    I took it as a "slight!" When they use cutting remarks like that, believe me most of the time it'll have negative connotations! Some will say she was for Seth Aaron because it was "a collection" instead of "a line" that Sosa produced, but I'll still take that comparison as a "shot!" I'm conspiratorial that way!


    Wretchen was a female filler; sorry! That's just the way it is or was this past season! The best designers were the guys! April repeated herself, HIvy was too busy creating drama, and our winner was just "gifted" a season! People really think and I concur, Mondo was too reminiscent of Seth Aaron; Nina and Michael really pulled for Wretchen at the end there! I really thought the boxing gloves were coming out next!

    They could have saved the show for me if they had played out a proper reunion show! It stunk; no real drama or conflict! It was just a love-fest for the most part! Even when the girls tried to get it going saying how "fake" our winner is, the guys came to her defense for the most part! IDIOTS! I was so looking forward to blood-shed! What happened? Hard to believe this keeps happening; poor or bad behavior getting rewarded again! Well at least I won't have to watch this crap anymore! "The Fashion Show" is on the way next month; thank GAWD! It has to be an improvement over this mess! Go Michael and Iman! - What an embarrassment! I checked for judges blogs and videos on MyLifetime, but only Jessica Simpson had the "balls" to talk about it! We all know where Heidi was going, but Michael and Nina "got a lot of "splaining" to do later! MORONS!

    ***Who was the fan favorite?***

    That's why I say this was one of the worst reunion shows ever; so incomplete! They didn't nail HIvy for her behavior, they skirted Wretchen's with most of the guys coming to her defense, and I didn't hear a fan fave! I would think it went to Mondo; the sympathy vote! I know it didn't go to any of the women! They were the only ones that tried to get some drama going saying how "fake" Wretchen had been! They were all friends, but after they saw her "backstabbing" comments, they were out for blood! I'm surprised Tim and Heidi were able to keep them in check and moved on seamlessly! Mondo and Michael stroking the situation made me ill! "We're good friends now!" Pls spare me! Did she pay them or something? I wouldn't have been that kind after all she put them thru! It was so unnecessary! She was confident in her own ability, but I can still see her maneuvering around the room as if she owned the place giving criticism and advice at the beginning of the season! "Screw you hag! You got your gift win! Move on and out of the limelight! You'll be as obscure as the rest of the winners of PR!"

    ***Have they ever just said who was out like that during their judging?***

    If you look back, they've done that many times; just totally throwing out a designer saying "they aren't in the running, can we agree?" Regular season and finales they've said that before! I agreed at the time, but that didn't stop them from making what I considered a bad choice in the end! If they were just a little more consistent I wouldn't be so upset! They backtrack, play both sides of an issue, and when warning someone of a design or color pallet, they only punish on a whim rather than being true to their word!

  41. ++The Fashion Show - Season 2++

    ***Hey...was the Fashion Show good?? I never watched it last year.....Iman is asceeeeering me!!! Issac is hard to watch on his talk show or HSN! But I wanna see how it is.***

    It was hard to watch a couple years ago! They were within their "growing pains!" Things were a little forced, you had a lot of dead and painful silence; esp. after a judgement! I guess we can compare it to the 1st season of Project Runway! PR never changed anything, but it wasn't as forced; IMO anyway! The Fashion Show was a lot like that; people were all but bumping into one another! It will definitely be a step up with Iman! - Here we go! Iman; Isaac; Fashion! In love with Rolando! Just my type; young, long hair, and just so hot & sexy! They got rid of the right person at least!


    The switch made sense to me! Both Cesar and Calvin are dominant personalities, but Team Emerald didn't have anyone over there who could at least challenge him! Team Nami will have some trouble with Calvin, but they aren't kittens either and won't let him run all over them as he did Team Emerald! Team Nami has a lot of confidence and I think they can handle the 'drama queen!' He's going to do what he wants regardless; let him cut his own throat and he'll be out soon enough!

    ***ITA! Plus, anyone on House Nami need only point out to his nastiness that Nami has won BOTH challenges, which is empirical proof that they can work together as a team and put out a cohesive collection.

    Am I the only one who thinks Isaac M. sold out when his designs started appearing at Target? I just can't respect the man anymore since I started seeing dog toys and cheap handbags with his name slapped on them.***

    It's just too much money to turn down! Only the top, top, top designers can tell large nat'l corp chains to "get lost" when offering an endorsement worth millions! I think I saw Isaac M. before along w/ designer that appeared on A-List: NY warning Austin to diversify and don't say "no" to an opportunity! It can all end w/ a snap of a finger! Easy for us and others to use that term "sell out!" Who can't you say that about? Even Queen Latifa has gone corp.; very polished actress and singer! She's a 'Cover Girl' now! The days of her wearing baggy clothes, 'hoodies,' and a doo-rag are long over!

  42. Was watching the last show before they went home to create their lines! I can't tell you how sick it made me to see Wretchen make it with that crappy effort! Poor April; if only she had come up with something different! Dumb repeat with the "witchy" dress! When they came back and you had Michael D, Mondo, and others defending her at the reunion, it was shocking! She was a complete bitch the entire season, but they give you this BS that they've gotten to know her and she isn't malicious! When you call someone the names she used, only evil intent could be reasoned!

    The girls jumped on her calling her "fake," but it didn't matter! She was rehabilitated I guess, but not with me! She could have at least come up with a great collection instead of that crap they allowed her to take the season! I really believe they were just looking for someone more commercial so they can sell on that idiot line promoted by PR! Just a horrid season! I only enjoyed watching the animus and jealousy of Hivy & Wretchen when Michael won his challenges! They were beside themselves with envy and hate! How do people dismiss that as just being their opinion and nothing else? Bullshit!

    ***What is the purpose of this show? - At the end of the day this show has always been a 'reality' tv show rather than a design competition. ...***

    You got it all covered! Just not one of my fave season! There are only a couple episodes I can watch over and over; the Team Challenge and the Bridesmaid remake over and over! Wretchen "lost it," was overbearing, then at the end didn't want to take responsibility for how badly their team worked together with dreadful creations! The entire group just jumped on Michael! I don't know how he can forgive that? He's a bigger man than me! Hivy and Wretchen's sourpuss faces and being green with envy after he won a challenge was priceless! "I won," says MC! "Of course you did," says Hivy! It was just too funny!

    It's unbelievable how people will try and justify their actions during that team challenge; throwing Michael C "under the bus!" How do you excuse the stuff coming out of their mouths; not editing? HIvy said, "I don't know if it's a lack of skill or just plain ignorance" referring to MC! Wretchen started the avalanche of "passing the buck" by attacking MC and totally dumping the failure of the team on him! I expected HIvy's bratty behavior, but how could Andy & Christopher get caught up in it? A.J. just stayed sorta neutral even though he knew he was in trouble only producing one bad "shirt dress!" This "team" challenge along with Michael's redemption in the bridesmaid redesign are the best and I just keep rewinding the tape! It has to be so embarrassing for all of them to see this replayed on Lifetime over and over!

  43. Wretchen & HIvy took disengenuousness to another level in that "team challenge!" As Wretchen's patting herself on the back for all she did to make her collection come together, she was ripping the other team's saying it wasn't cohesive and didn't tell a story! I wish I knew what story her boring collection was telling? "They had a sweater called a 'grandpa sweater;' WTF?" Team Luxe was so confident they had the winning line! When Heidi started rattling off names of "Team Lace," HIvy saw the handwriting on the wall! She exclaimed, "OMG!" I see something new and different every time I watch this episode!

    Chris and Andy are deluding themselves the entire time watching their creations on the runway; justifiably concerned too! A.J. was a no show making one rotten shirt-dress! Wretchen and HIvy can't be believed regardless of how much the guys stuck up for them at the reunion! You can't explain away all that bitchiness with the excuse of "editing!" That's BS! The words came right out of their mouths; "Michael C this and that...., he doesn't know how to sew, he doesn't know how to drape, ...!" HIvy went all the way; "I don't know if it laziness or just plain ignorance!" Just horrid comments coming out when they promised not to throw each other "under the bus!" How do any of them justify, explain, or excuse dumping on Michael C in the team challenge? He didn't create HIvy's hideous "Maude" outfit! Who produced those "grandpa sweaters?" MC had nothing to do with the styling! I just crack up ROFLOL every time I see this episode and wish I could be around when these people have to explain their boorish behavior! The only thing funnier was MC winning the next challenge redesigning those bridesmaid dresses; "IN THEIR FACES!"

    ***This has probably already been asked but..."does anyone LIKE Gretchen?"***

    I just can't think of any one giving positive feedback about Wretchen as her true face came into view! She won those 1st couple of challenges and it went to her head! It gave her license to critique everyone else's work, show Heidi what she was missing in her collection (..and to fill it), along with a very bratty attitude when someone else won a challenge! How many times did she say MC didn't deserve to win? So now she's a contestant, projected weekly winner, head judge, & personal consultant to Heidi! She was just too much and any goodwill I had for her was trashed in the blink of a velvet, batted eye! You wanted to dislike her even with her sob story!

  44. ++The Fashion Show - Season 2++

    ***I think that I'm in the minority when I say that Cindy should have gone home, for refusing to stand up to Calvin. Calvin is no saint, but Cindy is certainly capable of speaking her mind.***

    I'm no fan of Calvin, but I don't understand people thinking he should go home compared to who has been given the boot! I'm sorry, but what she did was horrible! It was ill-fitting, strange looking, and she should have known she was in trouble! The sleeves were puckering all over the place! Calvin may be a real jerk, but he put something out there that was finished! You have to get past your dislike for the man! He's obviously very talented and can create couture designs overnight; he made 2 or 3 for Teresa from RHWNJ a couple weeks ago! You can say Isaac and Iman are saving him for the drama of the show, but what has he done that should have auf'd him over another designer? His stuff is complete, polished, and wearable!

    If you notice, the other designers are still pinning hems a moment before the runway! I guess I understand Calvin a little more! I was quite the loner and couldn't stand working with a team! You can't depend on them! It gets old picking up the pieces from some that just don't care and you find it everywhere! I suppose he could be more personable, but it would be fake! I'd rather he just stay quiet and calm, but still be as creative! I'll have to use that line of his, "Me, Jay, working with people! Oh hell here come!" lol!! Must be why I chose to work with cold, calculating computers!

    I'll have to admit Calvin was totally unreasonable when it came to the color! Why push BLACK like that; wasn't a funeral, but a wedding? He has to be in a really bad place! I know after a week I would be ready to kill! As a consultant, I had to travel quite a bit back in the late 90's and early new decade! I made comments like "I need to get home to hug my walls!" After only 10 days, I went home early from a European trip! I should have been there at least 3 or 4 weeks, based out of Amsterdam, making day trips to neighboring countries! I just wanted to get back home in time to see the World Figure Skating Championships! I could have flown to Vancouver on my way back to California, but I hate paying those ridiculous prices for tickets! There's no instant replay, the wait is interminable for scores after a performance, and again, I just wanted to get home! I guess I'm just as disturbed as Calvin; BROTHER!

    My Gawd, what are they hiding during deliberation? Hard to believe they'd give designers another chance to improve a bad garment! How anti-climatic! I'll have to see the show again later! I think there was a lot more drama in S1! Hard to believe as "naked" as that show's production was, it's still better than this season even if you prefer Iman as a co-host! I miss the comical decision making; esp. the insults! We got "nothing!" Iman has insulted them to their faces enough, but the real dirt flies behind the scenes comparing and or destroying a designer's "taste level!" Funny I don't mind Calvin hanging in there! He almost "walked" trying to save another designer; "tearfully" early on! This was a good choice! Cesar hadn't grown, wouldn't edit, and his own ego got the better of him! He was so sure on certain decisions like those horrible swimsuits he cut and put together with "lost and found" items! The judges "mauled" him! He really never got better if you know what I mean!

  45. ***Halfway through he was in the lower half most of the time, yes, but he was never the worst.***

    You're kidding right? lol! Not the worst? If he wasn't, I want to know who was! His stuff was practically falling apart including that tacky jumpsuit glued together at the last moment for Kara Jinx! OMG, he should have been history then, save for how bad Nick was with his pant-suit for poor Daniel V! He should stick to commentary on "RuPaul's Drag Race" and skip his own designing! Notice he was booted in the 1st rung of "all-stars" the last time along with winners; Jeffrey among them! Poor Uli had to be shocked Chris March and Sweet P went on to the final rung of judging! Chris almost cried! So did I!

    ***Season 3 was the worst***

    Just goes to show everyone has to watch and get whatever content! I was no fan of Angela's either, but she gave as good as she got! She seemed to wander about a little in her own reality who actually started a lot of the conflict or issues you're bringing up! For someone that wasn't much exposed to the big city, she jumped right back at each assault with her own venom! She was looking for Jeffrey to abuse her mother, so that's the way it appeared! I hated Jeffrey, but what was he supposed to do with that cow? He wasn't as good a designer even though he won the season! He was helpless and frustrated, so after all his work to see her unhappy didn't help the situation! I know you're supposed to make the client happy, but the client shouldn't be able to just make your life miserable too just because she's miserable! I'm sure Anthony and Kayne's moms weren't happy, but did you feel bad for all concerned? They got thru it; it was a challenge, not life!

    Season 8 was a joke after all is said and done! It seemed surreal at times to me! I'm still wondering how Wretchen made it to the final after that "off the rack" number qualified her! As usual they go that extra mile to hose another designer; one who won a spot! Someone is always knocked out in some ridiculous extra judging of seeing just 3 of a designer's line! Let all 4 go like they did in Season 3! Jerell was screwed allowing Kenley to advance after her mermaid, flower dress! Chris March was overlooked for "Mr Rouche," Rami after ignoring the judges all season! There's no rhyme or reason for some of these decisions! There's no consistency at the end! It's obvious production is taking other things into consideration besides the talent of the designer!

  46. *******Season 9*******

    ***Are you guys familiar with The Tubey Awards? They just came out again and Gretchen is a nominee for best villain.***

    I'd never heard of it, but I guess there had to be something comparable to "the Razzie" for tv! Kind of a joke nominating her for best villain, at the reunion she got a complete pass! She had defenders including Michael C, who she excoriated many times behind his back! Hivy said "fake" and that was the extent of the attacks besides emails from us! So unsatisfying! She deserved to cry over her rotten behavior! lol!

    ***The only thing with the awards though, well, IDK if you can really call them awards, whatever, the thing is, they have so many nominee's in each category that it's really overwhelming. Esp. when there's a lot of people/shows that you love.

    Bert needs to go.***

    I just saw the (3rd) episode for the 1st time this morning! Bert may not be the most likable, a little lazy, and probably full of himself, but this was all on Viktor! From the button choices thru the idea of the garment, Viktor was mostly at fault! Know what you're talking about; "...a little more Victorian with the breast out to here...!" BS, this dude is clueless! "Hello, Victorian is the definition of prudish" and no way would anyone's breast be hanging out like that! What a moron! Bert was right when he said Viktor was very immature; "from the get!" - - Update: ..and Viktor's a liar! He definitely told Bert "this is your design," then said to Tim he "didn't say that!" What a punk!

    ***Not saying this to excuse Bert's behavior, I think both were pretty much equal-opportunity asses, but I think he was still pissy about Viktor's bitchy reaction to the two of them being paired up. Instead of taking the high road and making the best of a situation neither of them wanted, Bert held the grudge and then both let it escalate to the point where it affected their work.***

    Exactly! You covered it! Unfortunately I'm the same way! I couldn't overlook that snipe from some punk! I didn't put up with that when I was young, I definitely won't put up with it now! lol! From last season, Michael C. showed what a saint he was by forgiving Mondo who was acting out from others comments!

    ***But in that situation Mondo realized Michael C wasn't as bad as he was made out to be. All Bert did was reaffirm what Viktor and the others thought of him, even making him worse than first suspected. ...***

  47. ***About people freaking out that Gretchen won, sometimes I think they really didn't look at the clothes with an objective eye and just wanted Mondo to win; b/c Gretchen was a bitch. .., but so many people had such a strong negative reaction to her that I really think some let their opinion of her as a person cloud their judgement of her as a designer.***

    Someone's either delusional or it's Wretchen coming out here to defend herself! lol! You get some of that with Jill of RHWNY and Teresa of RHWNJ! It's so blatantly them and the board swarms over them like a pack of wolves! lol! She started out well, her head swelled to obscene proportions and it was all downhill after that! She shouldn't have even qualified with that "off the rack" number produced at the end! I thought I read out here, she's concentrating on her accessories instead of clothes! So it was a bit premature to deem her best over Mondo or even Michael C.! She beat him to death along with HIvy and I just can't understand how they got away with it! Even at the reunion they didn't pay a cost once you saw all those hateful confessionals on camera!

    ***Is Josh M. the new Gretchen? - The only difference is Gretchen did the same clothes over and over and over with the same drab, ugly colors. Both are bullies, both have underlying issues with difficult pasts. Josh is not dealing with loss in his life very well; Gretchen's family life and basic abject poverty drove her to be a class one BITCH! I am not at all impressed with Josh's design skills either. He may have been right to a certain degree about Becky, but he has serious issues and not a ton of talent to back it up (maybe it is taste level). Then again, there is the loose cannon Bert too!***

    You covered it as well as I could! Passive-aggressive is right for Miss Wretchen! I'm still ticked she wasn't taken to task at the reunion! She went relatively unscathed as poorly as she behaved that season; esp. towards Michael C.! It was irrational, classless, and showed how insecure she was by belittling his efforts at every turn! Why should she care what he's doing so much? Hivy and April weren't much better! They seemed to be more concerned about other designers work than their own! Just loved the Bridal re-do's that redeemed Michael! Too bad it was the old lady that got the ax and not one of the evil step-sisters!

    All the people around Josh "enable" him to act this way! He's a total "drama queen" that wants and needs people to fall in line with his way of thinking; and that's that! He's no compromiser on his best days, but on these bad ones, he's a true terror! I can tell his father even treats him with "kid" gloves! He's the type of person I keep at arm's length and would only associate with thru someone else! He wouldn't be on my speed dial; even a backup one!

  48. Poor Heidi Klum at the Emmys - Christian Sirano decided to make a statement at the Emmys! The only thing pretty about it was it was pretty awful! lol! The Fashion Police w/ Joan Rivers put her on the worst dressed list! Poor Seal was with her! She looked like a pinata with a yeast infection! Christian's so over the top! He should stick to his Payless Shoe collection! 617?cmpid=rss-000000-rssfeed-365-topstories&utm_source=eonline& ;utm_medium=rssfeeds&utm_campaign=rss_topstories

    ***That scrofulous bottom half looked like something from The Elephant Man. It was truly hideous.***

    He obviously has a following; I hear his name mentioned with other actresses, but they have to be teenagers or very, very thin! He likes making clothes for DOLLS; there's no mystery! It's impractical and I hope he soon recognizes to be even more successful, you have to be able to dress "real women!" They have curves and breasts! Left up to Christian, he'd have all breasts removed before a fitting! What an idiot!

    ***Dear Barbie, I mean Laura: - I understand why you're surprised that a somewhat-overweight short bald man could marry an attractive woman. ...***

    Funny I was thinking this topic related to Laura from Season 3! lol! She's a rather stunning woman with young children and her husband is older and seeming "out of her league!" The Barbie comment didn't register until later when I heard that woman use the term!" Why? lol! "I want to be Barbie!"

    ***That shade of pink...- I find it funny when not-sure-of-himself Bryce asked about his dress; so many of the designers made fun of the color or questioned the color ...Some said it looked like Pepto-Bismal.***

    Not like I cared one way or the other, poor Bryce was over his head! He wasn't going anywhere anyway! Might as well let him go now and he can get from under this needless stress! I liked the dress and the color! He just needed time to piece it together better; sans the pockets!

    ***Eva on "Hair Battle Spectacular" ... - I don't know if she's fake, but she does try to do too much. She uses too much expression, almost extreme gestures. I do like her better than the other host (Brooke Burns) though. I would like to see Derek J do some fantasy hair. I remember him from "RHOA," but he only styled a wig or two for Kim.***

    You must remember her mentor is Tara Banks! If you go back to ANTM, they've had instruction in doing things "over the top" with their eyes and body! She's just following her training! Being "Fake" goes along with the facade of trying to appear interesting! I've seen her "off script" at a poker event and she's probably still as "street" and catty as she was winning that season of "...Top Model!" She was truly cut-throat if I remember correctly! Her type probably couldn't get along with other women, but loves being the center of attention as a "fag hag" in some club! Things could have changed, but I doubt it!

  49. ***What is up with Bert? The past few epis he's been sooooo happy all the time, which is in stark contrast to the way he was at the beginning of the season. He's always smiling and laughing now. ...***

    Josh probably oppressed him more than we knew! That last meltdown with him was so "out of control!" I might have left if not punched him out! lol! "I will not have this Bert!" Who the hell does he think he is? He's a punk while that is a mature individual he should try to respect a little!

    ***Olivier is gone; finally. His bitchin' about fat people was too much even for me to overcome since I did like him. No more of his whining and bratty behavior! Now he can go try to seek out his mannequin sized clients.***

    I tried to give Olivier every benefit of the doubt, but he finally broke me down! Bravo; justice is finally done! "Congrats Bert, you pulled it out!"

    ***OMG!!! After The Runway***

    I barely watched, but didn't Josh take immediate offense to what Laura had to say and blamed her for him being defensive? I heard him attack how old she was; "you're older than me, blah, blah!" I always think I've seen the worst character around until they walk right by again! This is another person in total denial; Josh and anyone that would defend him! lol! "Good luck! He'll break you heart!" lol! Josh's the classic fair weather friend! If he gets his way and you agree with everything he says, 'you're buddies!' Don't cross him; "I will not have it Bert!" OMG, "respect your elders punk!"

    ***She gets to Josh - the hostile pinhead - and asks if he is "embarrassed" by his actions. WTF? That is not a question meant to illicit a response; it is a question meant to illicit a defensive reaction.***

    I believe she was just asking questions she got online! Everyone here and on MyLifetime have had the same feelings about Josh! What is she supposed to do, go totally off topic and ask how he feels about his mother not being able to see him compete? People have a visceral dislike for Josh and she was compelled to illicit that "bratty behavior" of his since he doesn't see it! It was the same with Wretchen last season! No one wanted to talk about her crummy designs! The real conversation took place describing her "bad behavior" and bitchiness! Same for Hivy!

    ***When discussions on the boards wind up like this it restores my faith in civility. Thanks for not taking the low road with name calling...***

    No problem! I only lose my civility when something "very stupid" is said! I judge stupid to be some kind of "hate speech" or a total misrepresentation of an event or persona on the show! We can agree on who's the biggest jerk and act accordingly! When someone comes along trying to defend "bad behavior," we sometimes go off; I know I do!

    ***Anybody but Viktor***

    I can relate to Viktor, but at the same time understand why others have a natural dislike for him! He keeps stuff to himself for the most part, but because of the show he's making these comments during the confessional that make him look worse! I was a loner and had a lot of opinion about stuff! If someone had been following me around with a tape recorder, maybe I would have sounded the same!

  50. ***I liked Laura's finally 3 pieces better than Josh's. That being said, Laura's weren't GREAT either.***

    Laura wasn't going anywhere! She had the exact same persona as April from last season! You tell her about her taste level and she continues on! Tim even warned her in no uncertain terms and she still didn't adjust! Josh's designs may have been crap, but he has more aptitude to produce a collection than Laura! She complicates her life too much! Those circles were ridiculous! It looked heavy!

    ***Laura's gown had all kinds of fit problems that they didn't bring up. It was odd; they're not usually that forgiving on a normal week so why the sudden lenience?***

    Like April last season, Laura has taste issues! Tim tried to tell her, but like April using black and making witchy costumes, she doesn't listen either! She got called out on being 2-faced as well! "I'm just keepin' it real!" Yeah right, real dumb! We see the tape moron!

    ***I think Anya will win. The Judges pick the winner based on who will sell the most in their opinion. Anya has got to be more popular than Victor and will probably sell more. And they have had a test run to see how Anya's winning outfit sold from a past challenge.***

    Well that's not true all the time! They commented that Sosa's designs were very commercial and could be put out "as is" in Season 7! Seth Aaron has been missing in action as far as I'm concerned and I thought those weird costumes couldn't possibly win, but he did! I was wrong; a "collection" compared to Sosa's "LINE" as Michael and Nina told him! IDIOTS! They don't know what they want!

    ***Viktor was giving Nick Varos the stink-eye at the taping of "After The Runway!"***

    I can't stand either of them! Viktor has a rotten attitude and Nick is just all over the place! He has no taste and his designs looked trashy! Why is he so popular to bring back for these things over and over again? Kimberly is the antithesis of these losers, never bad-mouthing them or their designs and it really shocked her to see the betrayal of the so called "girl power!" She was hot "After The Runway!"

    I would have told Josh to "KMA" and take your fake apology and shove it if I were Becky! He's been bullied I'm sure, so he knows exactly what he was doing! For him to say it hurts him to be accused of such a thing; it's just all about him! If you tell someone to "go take a nap if you're tired, I'll do it myself;" what can be said? I'm just not that forgiving!

  51. ***Josh keeps making up rules***

    Thinking back, most designers are very honest about who they think should go to FW! A lot of the time there's a consensus that is un-mistaken and you can't sit up there looking like a goof trying to get your buddy a spot! Mondo wanted April last season; had to be a joke! She was totally in the bottom and had no real hope! Kenley going in season 4 made no sense since no one suggested her going besides a judge; if I remember correctly! She had rubbed people the wrong way including Heidi! The other times we've totally agreed for the most part; esp. for the top 2! There have been weak seasons like #4 & 5, but someone's got to win it!

    ***Really Josh?***

    Agreed! What a DICK! He can't be happy for someone else! He just can't help himself! I blame his father! Should have smacked some of that drama queen out of him! lol! "Woman please!"

    ***Tim totally owned Josh during his critique***

    His talent was always over-rated! Like Nick or Santino from Season 2, they're good for one or 2 designs; that's it! Forget about a collection! He doesn't have it in him; sorry!

    ***He is surprisingly restrained on his bitchiness this episode. He even seems somewhat humble in that he wasn't combative with Tim. I am kind of wondering if Anya won't get the boot b/c her pieces looked like everything else she's shown so far and Josh will go to fashion week as a result.***

    I'd have more sympathy if she hadn't gone on her usual hatchet job on the other designers! Why can't they worry about their own work? I hate trash talking even if it doesn't come out! For them, it all will come out! Can't wait for "After The Runway!" lol! Viktor "got off" on Anya's annihilation on runway! lol!

    Same 'ol BS! I hate this show...Total BS; All 4 are going! It looked as if it was a replay of last season; 1st selected is the 1st to go! Anya's collection was woefully lacking, but they wanted her; hence 4 are going to FW! - I guess we should have known they'd pull a fast one; if necessary! Anya fell flat, but they really wanted ex-Miss Trinidad so here we have 4 designers again! I thought the winner of last challenge would go home again like S4 with Jerell & Michael C. from last season! She was awful! This is definitely one of the weakest seasons ever! There's nothing luxurious about any of these designs! Looks more like off the rack at the more trendy stores!

  52. ***Was that Laura B. not liked on her season?***

    Laura's a New Yorker; obviously quite accomplished who has little patience with persons she deems "idiots!" I don't blame her for her altercations with Jeffery! I don't suffer fools very well either! He all but wished her to lose her baby; he was being so mature! It doesn't matter he just mumbled it under his breath like Bert, the world heard him! He was an arse and there's no defense to the way he talked to the ladies! He's a pig so I guess we shouldn't expect better, but he was abusive to not only Laura, but universally hated "Miss Sunshine," Angela, moving onto her mother Debbie! He never should have made it to the finale with that "milk-maid" number he had Merlinda sporting! She would have been embarrassed to go pick up the mail in that ridiculous costume! Like Anya, they wanted him so that was the 1st time they went to 4 designers just to save him! Austin Scarlet should have been the 1st "4th designer" to go to FW if anyone! He's been all over the place since season 2! Have we heard of Jeffery besides those hideous dresses he makes for Margaret Cho?

    ***She had conflict with the winner of the season, Jeffery when she accused him of cheating in the finale, b/c she doubted he was able to complete all his work so expertly before FW; ....***

    You noticed those gutless turds let Laura do their dirty work! They felt the exact same way actually going over to Jeffery's rack; "pulling craftsmanship out of his ass!" lol! Uli couldn't contain herself and re-iterated the fallout by announcing "Laura made Jeffery cry!" Bitch! I really hated Uli! Her designs were all the same and they allowed her to skate thru the season! Anyone else they would have nailed them for their "comfort zone!"

    You covered it all in the Michael C. situation on "Project Runway!" It wasn't as much he was socially awkward though! The animus was so irrational! A lot of it had to be some misunderstandings that may have taken place in the 1st weeks and those feelings couldn't be "let go!" If he got any kind of praise from the judges, the others would shake their heads and look around in disbelief; "what kind of competition am I on?" Most of it coming from "Wretchen and HIvy!"

    This season (All-Stars) he's "killing it" w/ 2 wins and one he should have won! I'm no fan; just the facts! Diane VF actually said to him, "Michael, you have to give me a call after the show!" She said it so blase and had physically moved on to the next designer shuffling thru her cards! It was priceless! I wonder what Gretchen and Ivy had to say about that? lol! It just cracks me up everytime I see it! Vindication and validation, all in a couple weeks!

  53. ***Biggest Bitch of All Seasons!? Poll!***

    As soon as I saw the thread, "HIvy's" name came to me right away! You might think it's only because she's so recent being from season 8, but no one was as vile and unrepentant as this woman! She really needs to be under the care of someone else! She just made no sense to me! "Irrational" was the word of the day with both HIvy and Wretchen! Even after they saw what they had done and said on tape, they just took no responsibility for their behavior to the end!

    ***Josh can definitely be a bully, but at least it's in the heat of the moment. Ivy singled out one person to pick on and then went after him relentlessly for the entire season. Even after she was kicked off, she magically came back from the dead just to be a bitch to Michael. I guess the difference is that while Josh may grow up and out of his bitchiness, Ivy's in it for the long haul. She is a truly nasty, mean spirited person. Some would say she may have gotten caught up in a mob mentality.***

    You're probably right! She's the consumate follower and cheer-leader! Wretchen may have started it, but HIvy definitely had it in her mind she would "finish it" and no one was going to outdo her! She took it to the next level on Michel C. that she probably still doesn't see! Another show, "Top Chef," had this chef from S1 called Tiffani! Everyone hated her guts, she always had something nasty to say and was unrepentant until a few years later! She acknowledged her bad behavior, made a complete recovery, and now has the support of fans! I'm not sure Hivy could admit to herself she did anything wrong! She'll probably be rememebered for all time and a villain and side-kick to Wretchen!

    ***HIVY was entirely different than Wretchen. That chick had more than a few screws loose, and was definitely NOT the kind of person you want to have scissors in their hand.***

    What does that say about the rest of the group? Either they totally agreed with Hivy's bullying of Michael C. or they were humoring her so she wouldn't direct her venom at them! April agreed with everything except her own "bad taste!" I still remember that horrible team challenge where Michael had immunity! All of them went off the script after promising not to "turn on one another!" I was appalled! Even after all his team mates "threw him under the bus," HIvy had to add on that she "didn't know if it was Michael's laziness or just plain ignorance!" She really should have been called on the carpet for that one; by the judges at least! At the reunion nothing happened! Wretchen totally got away with it also! There was no retribution or justice after a horrible season of tasteless & classless designers!

  54. ***Gretchen apologised and Michael C accepted the apology on the reunion. Story over. If he can get over it, you can too!!***

    Whatever! That reunion wasn't worth watching more than once! Wretchen and Hivy never really paid a cost! MC was a fool to let it slide! Why should anyone believe they're sincere after all their talk and insults? I don't get over stuff that easily! You're only expressing your true personality when under pressure and need to vent against someone you don't even know; "LIKE NOW!" I'm not that forgiving! Just being honest unlike those "bent women!"

    ***I just watched the latest "After the Runway" interview and he just kept patting and rubbing Anthony Ryan. Anthony looked like he was going to crawl out of skin each time Josh touched him. Ick.***

    Well he must have been in limbo since he was the only one defending Josh against Laura B.! I don't understand why these people just can't answer a question instead of analyzing it and taking it as an attack! These guys are in the wrong business if they can't take criticism! Buyers won't be as charming as Michael; they'll just leave and you won't even know what's wrong! "Listen, learn idiots!" Gawd help us all with these whiny bitches!

    I'm at a loss why the judges hammer an effort just because the accessories are lacking! So what! That shouldn't take away from a design! I've seen them "kill" a designer for improper hair, makeup, shoes, & bags! Why not say this could have been a winning design, but for the styling! They don't do that a lot of the time! It always goes too far for the entertainment value I suppose! Michael just loves humiliating these guys! Heidi and Nina not much better! They're merciless at times!

    ***When did sob stories become a requirement?***

    You're getting it everywhere these days! I was watching "CHOPPED" on The Food Network the other day and one of the finalists mentioned she had just found out her mother was hit by a car the previous day! I almost vomited! "SO? What do you want lady?" Call me a cold fish; "everyone's got a story!"

  55. ***I'd be happy with either Kimberly or Viktor winning!***

    Unfortunately they were the first to go! Congrats Anya and Josh! Total BS, but congrats for making the final 4! - Bert temporarily took that smile off Anya's face "After The Runway!" He preferred Josh's collection on the runway! After all he was put thru from that child, he heaped on the praise!

    I wouldn't have given it to Josh b/c he just replicated his "orange bird" dress to blue for FW; down to the chain under the arm! I was surprised no one brought that up! You would have thought it was something new and innovative listening to Michael K.! There was just too much fawning "on and on!" It was as if there were 4 complete collections with just little comments of disapproval! "A lost opportunity" isn't as harsh as calling Viktor's transparency designs "hoochie mommas!" lol!

    Runway judging was too calm and relaxed as far as I was concerned! I want to hear some real insults; "make 'em cry!" lol! Tim may have helped out too much! They seemed to change their entire collections in those 2 days! I wonder what would have happened if Tim had allowed them to go out there before his appraisals?

    ***Great question! And I completely agree with your assessment! Bert must be drinking again:) Honestly that orange thing I never cared for anyway b/c,aside from the color and the prom corsage, it looked like a toga with a pocket watch chain in the arm pit. And that is exactly what one of the black dresses in the finale looked like. Please; he used that plastic stuff on the black several times.

    I too thought the judges were too nice and there was way way too much fawning. I am with you...more insults:) - I really don't know whose finale collection I liked best. ...Did you see Bert's decoy collection? Personally I thought it was gorgeous. Plain in a way, and very simple, but super classy and wearable.***

    I glanced at it a week ago, but can only remember I liked it enough! With time and money I would think Bert would probably come up with a classier show, keeping it simple! I was wondering about the brows on Viktor's models and saw where the "artist" suggested a more masculine look; (yuck) They really looked like "extras in a horror movie" on 1st glance! I thought he would have had a better collection given the extra time and material additions w/o a need to come up with a "13th look!" I was surprised a twist didn't appear at the end! I have this feeling Tim went to the judges and told them "do not do that to them! They aren't ready as it is!" lol! They totally transformed those collections! You can call it editing, I call it a complete re-do!

  56. ***Josh's Critiques were WAY TOO NICE!! - they seemed to have negative critiques for everybody except Josh. They didn't say one bad thing about him (even those God awful green shorts) - From where I was watching, he had the most random collection of them all and I hated most of his pieces! Sure some of it was "risky" and "editorial", but as a whole I didn't get it.***

    Well maybe they were giving Josh more credit for having a "complete collection" rather than "a line" as they painfully used against Sosa in season 7! Total BS of course! They allowed Anya to be "Johnnie one note" with all those dresses! Uli was punished for the same thing! There's just no consistency; no rhyme or reason anymore! I wouldn't have even allowed Anya to go to FW w/ what she offered as a preview! She should have been embarrassed! The judges will come up with a reason; Heaven knows they stretched it with Wretchen last season!

    ***... I really thought Viktor would have pulled out all the stops. And the "black see-through" stuff just looked out of place for him. It was really weird. - The lack of a twist surprised me too! It always seems to bring on very entertaining breakdowns! - Anya deserved it. People will try to find any excuse to put her down. In the end she's charming, talented and has a future.***

    She won overall, but I think the field was rather weak! Their design and fabrication time was radically reduced! Anya pretty much threw stuff together at the last moment! It paid off though! I've seen a lot more elegant and glamorous creations! I think what bothered me the most is how much they were allowed to change, not just "tweak" their collections! There was a complete re-do after assessment by Tim and the judges of the "best 3 looks!" It was a crime that they totally transformed all the lines! I keep wondering what would have happened if they were tested with a 13th look? Some of the decoys may have been better; esp. Bert's!

    ***...I don't think her win was all that solid- after all she admits to not knowing much about sewing, didn't produce much back home during the 5 week run-up to FW, and seemed to have a major crisis in self-confidence when they got back to N.Y. - I don't have a problem with her win and I congratulate her, but it was far from a slam-dunk.

    But the same can be said of any designer who had won. No collection was perfect or up to par like in past seasons. It was a bad season, admittedly. ...I honestly thought Viktor would have won, but he seriously missed the mark with those 5 sheer pieces.***

  57. - - - - - PROJECT RUNWAY ALL STARS - - - - -

    I can get behind your list to a point! Your top 3 are my bottom 3; that's it:

    Irina (6) - Probably one of the most talented designers; just ask her
    Seth Aaron (7) - Too costumey, but Sosa was such a pompous jerk I didn't care
    Leanne (5) - The most delicate and feminine collection ever with those petals
    Chloe (2) - The safest designer they ever picked, but she was good enough
    Gretchen (8) - A travesty; more ego than talent
    Anya (9) - I'm feeling she just replicated "ULI" from season 3
    Christian - (4)- Should've been auf'd very early on; totally unwearable designs
    Jay (1) - He just had a really lucky time with bad competitors who didn't listen
    Jeffrey (3) - Another designer that should have been auf'd real early

    ***Thought I would start watching again only to find no sign of Heidi, Tim, or any of the other judges! Why did they completely change it?! Is it just for this season b/c its All Stars or what's the deal? - According to Tim Gunn, they were still recording last season when All Stars started. As for Tim, he didn't feel he could devote time to both groups of designers.***

    I was quite shocked to see Isaac since he's associated with Bravo's, "The Fashion Show!" Does that mean no more of that since he's now on Lifetime doing PR? lol! It was a replacement show to begin with! They were supposed to be in opposition! Someone sell out? I didn't watch that runway show afterwards! What was that all about? They want to stick to a formula so much that they run the exact same show with different contestants; at the same time? MORONS!

    I wonder will Angela truly call Michael to see about wearing his black, feathered dress from last night? It was gorgeous! That's gotta really upset people like Hivy and Wretchen who had nothing good to say about this guy! He's killin' it! Other designers are favorably mentioning his work during fabrication! He's on the right track regardless of how he comes off!

    What was Rami doing playing with Anthony's hair and head; sorta like a pet? lol! Austin was practically sitting on Kara's lap talking "Couture!" - Michael's killin' it! I thought he might win the challenge, but Austin snatched it at the end! Lucky! I thought the gold lame was as gaudy as anything he's done in the past! It figures Mila thought it was plain! She's always wrong about other people's designs! They really skipped a lot of designers during the fabrication! If not for the runway we wouldn't know anything about Mondo's offering along with many others! "April, April, April; what are we going to do with you?" Will she always fall back on old tricks? She'll be next to go, if not Kara!

  58. ***The Broadway Challenge was a bit of a disappointment.***

    Michael probably could have taken the challenge with another piece; shawl or shrug! It was so bare compared to others who made jackets and other elaborate tops! They also didn't like his styling with the "too matchy" strap on the shoe! I think Mondo's design was hurt with the length and almost bare feet wearing sandals! I don't need to see the pedicure; cover those toes!

    ***Did anyone actually like Austin Scarlet's design?***

    I find his designs very "costumy" and impractical for street wear this season! Perfect for the stage, but an absolute joke anywhere else! This week, I hated it even though very polished and good for Broadway! I still think back to dress he made for Miss Piggy; "the bows!" What was he thinking? More laughable than anything!

    ***Only Mondo and Rami seemed to challenge themselves and only a very little. They are talented, but have a limited range. Where are the all-stars?***

    These are all far from "All-Star!" True all-stars don't have the time for this BS! Even winners of seasons are a little to be desired; Jeffery, Irina, & Jay! The time constraints would do in Leanne! They're rushing thru with designs having to be done in 24 hours, but it's still taking a while to shoot and you're stuck there even after being eliminated!

    It's been predictable each elimination even when the judges try to throw you off with their comments! I haven't felt an upset of any kind even when Mondo thought he had a challenge nailed and wound up in the bottom! He deserves to be there, but even though his stuff is immaculate, there's something about it; maybe unwearable by a normal woman! The miss-match patterns and polka dots can't be worn by some "beasts" that's for sure!

    You can say the same about Michael's designs, but he surprises every one concerned each week! The other designers think he's going to be in the bottom, but is in the top most of the time; or high end of the bottom sans that outfit re-do from "a muse off the street!" So far it's gone according to script with little difficulty deciding on who should go! Heaven knows it seems they were saving Kara and Kenley to keep it simple among the remaining guys near the end; Mondo, Austin, & Michael!

  59. ***The final 3 s/b Mondo, Austin and Rami. Now that Rami is gone, I'm afraid that somehow Michael will make it in! And if he manages to make it in, these clueless designers might just pick him. Ugh!***

    Wow, the "hater-aid" is flowing on this board! lol! Sounds a bit irrational! If you want to club him over the head for repeating a past design, that would make sense! His "Statue Of Liberty" dress was replicated in this pageant gown with the big blue bow! It had the exact same silhouette for the most part; sans be-jeweled collar! That's rational! Anything else ya got? Rami has been styling for old ladies for the most part! That roushe green top was so heavy and hideous! Loved the jacket, but he had to go! Jerell's on borrowed time! Kenley soon to follow! Who else is there but Michael, Mondo, and Austin!

    ***They should change the name to Project Runway Losers!***

    All of these shows do the same thing; an all star season with their better competitors! They've done it here w/ Daniel V.(2) winning over Korto(5), Sweet P(5), & Chris March(4)! Santino(2) & Jeffery(3) were elim. early along w/ Uli(3) & Michael (3)! This all-star season, even though it has been easy to eliminate them so far, were the creme of the crop! They obviously have time on their hands even though they're rushing thru the season! You have some all-stars that are better than others! Kara, Jerell, Mila, & Kenley are on one level while Rami, Austin, Mondo, & Michael won quite a few challenges in their own seasons and this one!

    ***I think Michael is going next...his outfit was interesting, but seemed forced to me. It's like he's losing steam. A finale with Austin, Kenley and Mondo would be fabulous, b/c they're all so unique. They're definitely the most artistic. While I want Kenley to win, I'd be equally happy with Austin or Mondo. ***

    You have a bit of the "one-trick" pony dilemma; Austin (couture), Kenley (polka dots), & Mondo (textile mix/match)! Michael specializes in draped gowns, but he's come up with all kinds of designs and can be just as innovative as anyone!

    ***I agree, and I've always loved Michael. I just have a feeling that he's losing steam.... Personally, I'd like a 4 designer final!! I would also have loved to have seen his "Opera Dress" on the Oscar Red Carpet!***

  60. ***Last season the winning collection was made in what, 2 or 3 days and on a budget of $500? Surely they never have to give the designers thousands of dollars and several weeks to complete their collections again. I mean, after all, Anya didn't even know how to sew and she pulled off the win.***

    WTF are you talking about? They were gone for at least 5-6 weeks and even after all that time, 2 of 3 Anya creations looked like crap! All the designers took their critiques with some extra money and made changes plus finished the rest of the 10 piece collection! Producers didn't demand they come up with a collection in 4 days; the crap they had done while on hiatus was so bad, they had to be scrapped! That was their fault; no one else's! Anya should have been auf'd right then with that bathing suit and half-draped gold dress; just horrible! FIX is what people said after giving her chances to fix it again and again! Remember when she lost her money? Shazam, a reprieve to make a 2nd look saves her yet again! It just looked real bad with what they were doing for her! She got every break! Normally they would crucify a designer for bad sewing skills! Anya was not completing any of these designs; no zippers, buttons, or other openings, needing to sew model into the dress every time! No wonder some feel the way they do; the hypocrisy of it all!

    ***I'm hoping it's a 12-piece collection rather than a mini collection.***

    I thought they were still showing at FW; taped at the same time as S9! It has to be a mini collection due to them only having 4 days from what I heard of the preview! What ticks me off are all the harsh criticisms when they are demanded to create something in 1 day! "You get what you pay for idiots!" Isaac probably wouldn't take that kind of demand from a star, why crunch the time on them to produce? I know it's a competition, but it's still ridiculous to ask for beautiful things to be "run up" figuratively and literally overnight!

    ***They used Kenley's personality as an excuse to dump her. Her 'stubbornness' and 'unwillingness to take criticism.' A cowardly way out, IMO.***

    Demeanor has been taken in consideration before and it'll happen again! Heidi and the rest always say something like "you've been listening to us!" Kenley just dismissed her mentor; can't do that! I don't blame them for auf'n her! It should have happened a lot sooner as far as I'm concerned! If Michael's a one note, Kenley's worse stuck in the 50's and 60's! The only reason that dress didn't look totally dowdy and very old was because the model was so pretty! Every woman couldn't wear that dress without every wrinkle and bump showing! It's supposed to be a casual dress, but most women would have to wear "spanx" with it!

  61. ***...Let's stick to the design! Mondo didn't pull in the waist of his dress either when it was suggested and he won the challenge. Let's be fair.***

    Any and all the designers creations would have needed modifications! The main reason Kenley "went down" is she misrepresented what she was doing! She totally changed the design; missing "keyhole" was what made it marketable! "See, even you didn't listen!" lol! Michael's work isn't what I would have liked, but the judges swooned! He obviously is giving them what they want and Kenley's doing her own thing! Mila's work was like that; part of "her" collection rather than observing the challenge requirements! Stripes on Miss Piggy? PLEASE!

    What A Great Runway - They all did a great job for the amount of time allowed! Even with the negative comments, I'm feeling Michael as the winner! Mondo takes it though! As usual Austin just doesn't get it! That wedding gown just didn't fit!

    ***How did Gretchen end up winning with her granny panties? Her final collection wasn't exactly "young & fresh."***

    That's what I've been talking about for years, they're hypocrites and go against their own ideas of young and fresh all the time! When they selected Rami over Chris March in season 4, they were being narrow minded and hypocritical! The "hair" incorporated into his creations bothered them, now it's a staple in designs around the world! PR is a mess and getting worse all the time! Rushing to get designs done in 6 hours or a couple days just makes me sick when the judges come back complaining about it not being finished or creative! How creative are they under the same circumstances? Jerks!

    ***I was sooo disappointed with the choice of "All Stars". Where's Daniel V and Nick Verreos? Uli? Kara Saun? Michael Knight? Emmett? Santino? Chris March? I guess they're busy with real jobs. They have a collection of the most needy, annoying and unpleasant designers ever.***

    You all are just catching up! These are all far from "All-Star!" True all-stars don't have the time for this BS! Even winners of seasons are a little to be desired; Jeffery, Irina, Jay! The time constraints would do in Leanne! They're rushing thru with designs having to be done in 24 hours, but it's still taking a while to shoot and you're stuck there even after being eliminated!

    It's been predictable each elimination even when the judges try to throw you off with their comments! I haven't felt an upset of any kind even when Mondo thought he had a challenge nailed and wound up in the bottom! He deserves to be there, but even though his stuff is immaculate, there's something about it; maybe unwearable by a normal woman! The mis-match patterns and polka dots can't be worn by some "beasts" that's for sure!

    You can say the same about Michael's designs, but he surprises every one concerned each week! The other designers think he's going to be in the bottom, but is in the top most of the time; or high end of the bottom sans that outfit re-do from "a muse off the street!"

    So far it's gone according to script with little difficulty deciding on who should go! Heaven knows it seems they were saving Kara and Kenley to keep it simple among the remaining guys near the end; Mondo, Austin, & Michael!

  62. *****Season 10*****

    ***Ugh. Christopher makes me sick. I am afraid that the editing is too obvious at this point (in his favor). I would prefer Ven over him at this point.***

    Christopher may make you sick, but he was very complimentary to Gunnar giving him credit for his 2 "killer" dresses! Too bad Gun ruined it by letting us know how much he can't stand Christopher! This disturbed person actually said he can't stand Chris' voice! Obviously another deaf person who doesn't listen to his own whiny voice! lol! What a moron! I thought he had turned his rotten attitude around; WRONG again!

    ***I love how Elena had the nerve to criticize someone else for not being able to take criticism, esp. after her blow-up with Melissa.***

    Like Gunnar, she brings the drama! She wasn't going anywhere! She's a horrible human being, but they'll find a way to keep her longer! That was a fix; Gunnar on Chris' team; likewise with Elena on Dmitri's! Tim should be ashamed of himself! lol! He changed the way the teams got together in a blatant set up to make Elena and Dmitri clash along with Chris and Gunnar! Didn't work out totally! C & G were in the top with Sonjia! Shocking with Gunnar's comments just before they even started the project! He's looking a bit like a phony; more so than normal!

    ***What are your top 3 designs of the season so far? - Christopher's 1st runway dress with the pleating. Elena's Lord & Taylor black dress with harness design. Dimitri's print with peekaboo jacket.***

    Sounds good to me! I'll just agree! I think the group has been rather weak overall! Only 4 had a real chance from day one; Chris, Ven, Dmitri, & Sonjia! I'm finding Ven limited and he'll probably get auf'd before the finale! The others like Ven have a POV that the judges aren't going to let them get away with; hense bullying of Dmitri not to make a dress! What difference does it make if it's hot, original, wearable, & sellable? Loved the jacket!

    Ven much too sensitive! Like Rami from S4 and "All-stars," he's established, has a POV, and is over-confident! He was crushed by Tim's critique and was practically bawling later! What a weiner! Normally I'd have sympathy, but his attitude from day one has been so "above" everyone else! He needed a reality check; and he got it big time! lol! A homage to the menstrual cycle? OMG! He was just devasted! lol! "Good job TIM!"

    ***Tim was just being honest, not trying to tear Ven down. I don't get the whole crying thing. If he felt that strongly he could have just finished his dress as it was and disregarded Tim's comments.***

  63. ***I'm not a fan of Sonjia. She does construction well, but it's my opinion that there are stronger designers in the competition. She makes nice jackets though.***

    ITA! I did have a problem with her manic act a couple weeks ago! It was the most bizarre thing I'd seen in 10 seasons! She was actually having a nervous breakdown trying to dress her model! Her partner had to do it for her! It just made no sense!

    ***I'm definitely Team Dimitri. His jacket was amazing and I liked the fact that he listened to the judges and did separates instead of a dress.***

    I asked it before and I'll ask again, what is thg deal? If Dimitri wants to do only dresses, all he has to do is make them well! We've had other designers who have a POV and relentless do their thing without incident! What's their problem? Did they nail Anya, Uli, and Rami for continuing to rouch everything he did? Such hypocrisy and double standards! His dresses have been amazing, "shut up Heidi!"

    I've asked this once, but I'll have to ask again! What was the deal with Tim coming out during the judging process? I turned around for a minute, then turned back to see him gabbing with Heidi about what he said to Ven! I guess they wanted to make sure it was memorable! lol! It was! It shocked the entire room! Christopher is still blushing! lol! "I can't believe he said that!"

    ***Heidi asked someone to go get Tim because the judges were so baffled that Ven would have the balls to show them yet another flower design. She had asked Ven on the runway if no one - not fellow designers, not Tim - had ever said to him that that he needs to stop with the 'fan/flower' technique and Ven said 'no'. She couldn't believe that, so during the discussion with the other judges she asked for Tim to come out.

    Heidi being especially rude on this episode? - I found her to be cold and harsh this last episode. Like, more than usual. Anyone agree? Maybe it's the divorce while filming? - It just seemed like all of the judges went on and on in the previous two episodes, dogging the outfits over and over and kicking the designers a few times after they were down. Nina too!***

    Believe me, I've heard this same thing before! Over 10 seasons, they've all been rather catty and rude offending all concerned! They're harsh, cold, and insensitive at times, but they explain to the designers "this is a tough business!" They have to expect even worse treatment; believe it! No one loves to be critiqued, but even mild concern can offend a person who has it in their minds they're doing a great job!

  64. """Christopher's dress didn't move either, and I doubt you could see the skyscrapers from a distance. Dimitry should have won several times when he didn't, including this one.***

    Ditto! They were both nice! Christopher has the edge though by his "fawning!" He's young and the judges must love "the wide eye!" Poor Dmitry has to be discouraged! They went on and on about his design only to give it to Christopher! The long knives will come out soon; mark my word! lol!

    ***The ladies dresses are hideous - Elena's was absolutely awful. It looked like a tacky ice skating costume.***

    Why are people surprised? I don't know if it's a rip off from somewhere else, but I remember an infamous line in "Boys In The Band" from Emery; " takes a fairy to make something pretty!" (paraphrasing a limerick or song) That's happened so many times where the girls are pulling their hair out while the guys are in a groove, finish early, and help the girls out! Kinda sad at times! Why does Elena keep fighting to stay? She's having such a rotten time of it! Her act has grown so old! Sonjia didn't help my opinion of her either! They're so easily thrown off, lacking an emotional connection to their work, then are shocked when they are allowed to stay! ENOUGH!

    ***I'm sad Elena left. I wish it was Melissa. I just... don't... get... Melissa. ?***

    Melissa should be next to go! She may have talent, but her designing process is entirely too slow! She won't be able to come up with a mini collection in 3 or 4 days! She might as well "get to packin'!" She streses almost as much as Elena! That was weird surfin' by and seeing everyone else gone while Mel's is still sewing! She really should have been auf'd right then and there! People had to have told her "it's time" and to get her butt out there on the runway! That really ticked me off; totally ignoring people and the situation! At least Elena was done so she was truly saved; for what I don't know!

    ***We cracked up when Sonjia said that mother looked like Mary J. Blige!***

    I turned away for a few minutes when Mary J. was sorta "going off!" What did she think she was doing? Chris has one day to make 2 complete outfits and she was like "no, never!" I couldn't believe it! Did she expect elves to wander into the work room and magically make her happy with something else while others slept? I was so glad she came in and apologized! Chris luckily kept on working even though she seemed to hate it! I thought they were flawless! Both mother and daughter could have walked out of the studio and no one would stare wondering "WTF!" Mary J.'s dress fit like a glove even though she wasn't the most svelte of the ladies! I can understand her balking at the print, but it worked!

  65. ***Once again, Christopher is overrated.***

    And so it begins! lol! I figured the other designers would have out "the long knives" due to Chris' wins! I guess I should have figured viewers would chime in the same way; over-rated being used mostly! Must be a weak season; as usual! You can't expect glamour overnight! A day to do something this major isn't going to be as polished! I think these designers have done a great job for the most part!

    The top guys had to be Christopher and Dimitry! I am shocked that Melissa went 3rd! So between Sonjia and Fabio they went with......Fabio! Now that was shocking; Sonjia gone? OMG!

    ***It was tough for me, because Sonjia and Fabio are my two favorites. However, based on this challenge alone, Sonjia was the weakest. I find it ridiculous that Melissa is the last female standing. She's weak.***

    Sonjia was losing her "mojo!" She's terribly talented, but she was having problems near the end; sorta like Gretchen(8)! Unfortunately the others had more noteworthy efforts tonight and someone had to go!

    *** I'm happy Dimitry's still in, but I'm also nervous he'll be out next week. Both Jerell and Michael C won the top 5 challenge. You'd think that the winner of the final challenge would get to go to FW, but both got elim. from the top 4 when they got back to NYC.***

    Tell me about it! I raised "Holy Hell" about it back then! You beat me to it this season! If you go by past history, the injustice would be to eliminate Dimitry and move Fabio in there! His work was ok, but it wasn't as effortless and D's seasonal designs! The judges are really at odds; openly! We sometimes hear about it later like with Wretchen winning season 8! Last night I thought it was going to change into MMA; Heidi loved something while Nina and Michael hated it and visa versa! Something strange is going to happen; mark my word!

  66. ***...I'd like to watch some seasons, and I'm wondering which ones are considered the best, or which ones you all think I'd most enjoy...***

    The season winners on the cover so SPOILER alert! Also have addition of "The Fashion Show" which succeeded PR on Bravo; Iman & I. Mizrahi! I started storing comments from the show; mines and others around season 3 of PR! Let me think on it and I'll update this post! Off the top of my head, check out season 3(good)! The novelty challenge has to do with recyclable materials; plastic, foil, paper! Season 5 has them using materials they could rip out of a car; seat covers, belts, and buckles! Season 4 has a Hershey's candy challenge too! I didn't see it, but I heard Season 1's novelty challenge materials from a grocery store! Season 2 used plants and flowers!

    ***Season 3, 4, 5 and 7 really go all out with the novelty challenges. However S 1 & 2 are full of great challenges too. I'd avoid S 6, 8 & 9. They aren't very good at all.

    They only got 5 weeks to make their collections? Didn't they used to get 3 months?***

    That "used to be" the case! For the last couple seasons, they've cut collection design time! May have started with Season 9 & All-Stars; quick turn-around and a couple days to tweek them! No 11th look either!

    ***For the first time EVER....I would honestly be happy with any of them winning. I know not everyone here feels that way, but I think they are definitely the best 4 designers of this season and I'm totally okay with this finale. I am pulling for Dmitry and Fabio, though, but I still wouldn't be pissed if Chris or Melissa win, even though I don't think Melissa has any chance of winning. I've never felt that way about a PR finale before.***

    They are all good and well deserving of the title! Chris has been my fave, but I wouldn't be upset whomever wins!

    ***And you know what-I like Fabio and Dimitry so it doesn't bother me which one wins. At least there are no "granola" styles, LOL ***

    They already decided that much! lol! Maybe Chris can make the All-Stars in time! Better luck next time Mels!

  67. ***DIMITRY SO DESERVED IT! I fk'n loved his collection. I could not be happier.***

    Wel deserved and it was his time! It was running out for him! He needed this!

    ***I've never heard they have to make their own shoes and jewelry?! That would be insane.***

    The 1st time I heard of a shoe issue was at Season 1's finale! Kara Sawn had a friend make her some shoes and wasn't billed! Wendy had a hissie fit and made Tim Gunn harrass her for a bit, making her get a bill, and taking money from her limited budget! She could use the shoes regardless, but if she couldn't come up with a bill and loss of money, the judges weren't allowed to take them into consideration! How they could do that made no sense; like they're just going to pretend they went down the runway barefoot? Idiots!

  68. ***Tim Gunn was quoted as saying to Heidi that he thinks the designers need more time, the show won't be as good if people aren't producing good quality stuff and they can't do that if they're exhausted and rushed.***

    "Time" has little to do with how tacky and cheap some of the designs appear! Something can be rich looking and very expensive, but done overnight if the right materials are bought and the taste level of the designer is good! I think the designers have been using that as an excuse for the last fews years on why their designs look a little listless, tired, and cheap! Someone like Laura Bennett can make something look "rich" within hours it seems! Her collection by far in Season 3 looked the most expensive; $8,000 made to look like $30,000+ per MK! I can tell you, if you give people more time, they'll just waste a lot of it over-thinking the process and get just as little done! People like Santino(2), Michael(3), & eventual winner Jeffrey(3) offerings looked quite cheap and they had months to get their work done! Sosa(7) the most impressive runner-up who was very commercial and they zapped him for it; IMO!

    ***I hate it when past winners come back as judges, whoever they are. They all sit there holding their cards and acting as if they were big names in the industry. It's embarrassing, really.***

    They need the exposure! lol! How many winners have never gone on to do "anything?" So many have faded from sight and the show has to bring them on periodically so people know they're still alive! lol! Usually runner-ups do better proving PR knows little and embarrasses themselves all the time with their lame picks like Jeffery(S3), Wretchen(S8), & Anya(S9)!

    ***What is a decoy runway show?***

    Starting with Season 1, production had an eliminated designer create a collection to throw people off concerning the winner since the show is taped so many months before it's telecast! Austin Scarlet's was the 1st decoy/dummy collection created! Since then they have been known to go back to the 7th or 8th designer which is why so many collections are shown in mags and blogs before the eventual winner is revealed! Only the top 3 or 4 are judged for the competition and are shown on Bravo!

  69. ***Why did the contestants have to be ready and out of bed at 2 a.m.? What time did they have the actual show? And why was it necessary to have the show so early in the day?***

    When it comes to production, the real work that goes on to create FS starts early! I'm not surprised because time flies when you're busy! Every since season 1 the designers have walked over to BP in the middle of the night to start working! My guess is that PR needs to get in and get out before noon for the rest of FW to finish up with established designers!

    ***Will there be a reunion show?***

    It doesn't look like it's going to happen! PR is jumping right into All-Stars thurs.! Maybe something is online! I haven't looked at the site all season on!

    ***... but usually we don't unless there is some drama to be milked from it.***

    Maybe that's why "no reunion" this season; little DRAMA! Oh well, that's what happens when the guys respect and like one another! Elena's rants weren't enough for exposure to conflict in a reunion show! Remember she apologized for her behavior before being auf'd!

    ***All men and only one woman; again?***

    I don't know why this should be surprising? What is that old saying, "Mary, it takes a fairy to make something pretty?" lol! It's the same thing for the cooking shows; mostly men, few women winners! On PR we have had only a couple seasons that had mostly or all women and they turned out to be weak season winners! I loved Chloe, but PR winner? NOT! Season 5 and 6 epitomized what I'm talking about! Irina won S6, but not without complicating it by assuming people were copying her designs! Season 8 & 9; nuff said! Both Wretchen and Anya were weak at the end and barely squeaked out their wins! JMHO! Anybody? The big winners have been men with Christian (4), Seth Aaron (7), Mondo (All-Star), & now Dimitry (10)! Most, if not all of the female designers have faded into obscurity!

  70. +++The next several Posts from Seasons 3 that didn't transfer over+++

    Keith is sexy in his own way, but a typical bad boy always bending the rules! He was more than a borderline criminal! People call it charming when they are really being manipulative! It was an attitude with him that really turned me off! "Don't be upset Keith, but I think you're using and I don't mean candy cigarettes!You just have that "dark" look that a cold shower and coffee can't snap you out of!" I'll take "Clark Kent" anytime; Robert is hot and beefy!

    With S3 off and running, it's a bit early for predictions, but I can hope for Uli, Robert, and the redheaded Madam, Laura! She is so classy and so reminds me of my Mom; always put together and stays up with the times! Uli makes Heidi harken back to Germany and Robert is just so damn cute! He's got that Clark Kent thing nailed! Woof!! Unfortunately his cloths suck! He's been on the chopping block twice and barely survived! Kayne is going to be the death of us all with his ego and sly demeanor hiding a dark side! It ate him up to see Angela win last week and then Michael this one! It wasn't enough for Kayne to supply the gown for Miss USA to compete at Miss Universe pageant last month!

    Who is dressing Heidi this season?? It's not that I don't like the stuff, but most of it seems dated; maybe retro! People shook their heads at the brown hot pants number last week and this week, oh my GAWD; drag out the go-go boots! Her hair has been rather strange of late too! Bradly was dumped today a week after Keith's ignominious end after getting caught with pattern making books, consulting the internet, and running out on the show for a few hours while he saw his 'boyfriend!' This guy is always looking for an advantage! It was so justified kicking him off the show!

    On Bravo TV PROJECT RUNWAY Message board, someone commented they didn't know much about Pam Grier of late!! I wondered how they could miss her:

    "I don't know how you can miss "Miss Grier!" Since Jackie Brown, she has been all over the place! From bad movies like John Carpenter's Ghost, to a reoccurring role on Law & Order: SVU as a FBI chief, thru some role I heard she played on The L Word, she has been a very busy woman! She's put on a few pounds, but she's not a young woman! It's hard to maintain that rail thin look with sexy T & A! lol!"

  71. Anything using subjectivity and judging will produce quite a few injustices! Nothing pains me more than hearing someone say it all balances out in the end! That is such a crock! Last season Santino made the final with designs created week after week that I wouldn't use to have people wipe their shoes on! Most of them were vulgar pieces absolutely falling apart, but he got thru because he caused so much drama! No one else was more full of themselves! We don't always hear about the lives of the one's unjustly kicked off the show after one Boo Boo; poor Andre! You have Angela wowing everyone now when by all accounts from the 1st weeks, she should be home crying her eyes out! Malan truly deserved to be there! The following week's decision was just as weak! To me Keith is this year's Santino! Not that he isn't talented, but there was something a little bit shady about this guy! Up to the last he thought it was ok to be a little deceptive and manipulative because "in the end I think I right!" What an ass! He would have gone far but for his self destructive behavior actually leaving the premises! Sheeshhh! I hope it cost him, but I can guess you can be successful even if kicked off early! I see quite a few of the old designers working backstage on tv shows and fashion runways!

    But I think you're off. Santino is this year's Wendy, so he'll make the final three no matter how bad his next design is. And they can really stink. His abrasive personality makes him good TV. The fact that the other three don't like him almost guarantees he'll be in.

    Both Daniel and Chloe have won. So they'll be in as well. Kara has been showing increased, steady improvement. But she hasn't won once. And I think she'll be out this week simply so Daniel, Chloe and Santino can be in. But...since she's in the final four, she'll still get to show. Her collection just won't make it to TV.

    Last year it should have been Jay, Kara Saun and Austin. But in order for Wendy to make the final three (undeserved as it was) one had to go. It was Austin. But notice it's Austin that's invited back, along with Kara Saun and Jay. Thankfully we won't be subjected to any more Wendy. Let her go play poker as a "celebrity". Hawk spit.

  72. Funny you thought Santino would be this season's Wendy! ...Checking out her site, she just might make it past Santino even though he may be more creative! I say that only because he says how talented he is every waking moment!

    Austin seems to be really getting around! He made celebrity comments in 2 entertainment programs on cable; 'Gays In The Cinema' and the other '20 Reasons It's Great To Be Gay!' He was a scream on both; especially giving Joan Crawford a break saying "Christina had no idea how hard her mother worked to get her those pretty dresses!" lol!! I can't wait to see Kara Saun, Jay, and Austin next week! I couldn't stand Wendy! She was just a bitter old woman!

    Like most of the people here, I just can't fathom at times the decision making process! They comment on designs being poorly executed or unfinished, but they let Santino and Kara skip to this position even though I thought Andre was a hell of a lot more talented! His garden dress was ok while Nick's looked like it would come undone if the model sneezed to hard! Santino's was no better! No accounting for taste MK!

    HOW SOON WE FORGET! lol! From the beginning of time, the best and most leading designers looked like they were dragged thru an alley! I felt so badly for Edith Head; she dressed them all, but she looked like a school marm poor thing! Miss Versace looks a little tired all the time! These days someone like Vera Wang is on the show, and like so many designers who work behind the scenes, what was so special about what she wore? Little if any makeup! Check out JAY (season 1 winner) today! All wild hair and dressed down!! As for Heidi, she's been slipping a bit! Who's been making her stuff of late; still Michael K?? lol!! Updated flower children type stuff really! I'm rambling! Anyway, I think Laura is always well put together, Alison is cute, Michael has his good days, and Uli is ok! Vincent and a couple others are destined to look a little wild; errrr eccentric!

    It's so hard to say at this time to pick 3 finalist! The judging is so inconsistent! Last season, 2 of them skated thru with garments literally falling apart while much more talented designers were axed for minor errors! Even on my own blog concerning the show I haven't touched it, but if a gun were put to my head, I'd select Laura (classy and keeps it fresh), Jeff (to be the resident badboy), then Uli (she works with patterns and fabrics most shy from! Even though they are family, Kayne and Michael grate on me! As pics label them time and time again, they bring the gay to the office! Love Robert, but he's been so close to elimination, Alison is too nice (ya gotta be cutthroat in this business), while Angela and Vincent just can't make it thru in my opinion! I can only hope justice will be served! At least Keith didn't piggyback his way to the final! He was just too full of himself! Most of them can be like that, but his attitude was just "I'm so entitled to be here!" Well that went wrong real fast! My selection for dismissal will be Angela!

    Even when the designers are blown away with criticism, they insist on using the usual buzzwords of classic, fresh, timeless, modern and it is so NOT the case! ...So far, the only elimination I question was Malan! Angela should not have skated thru with that Bimbo outfit for one! Robert's been just as lucky! I expected a little more out of Vincent with his experience! Alison is holding up very well so far!

  73. I know how you feel! I mentioned the same thing on another message string; too many designers are axed after one "Boo Boo," while other wacky contestants who promote drama march on! Last year it was Santino and Mr "fishtail dress," Nick! Most of their garments literally were falling apart on the runway! That Jumpsuit for Kara was glued together while Nicks party dress made out of leaves was one of the most vulgar pieces I've ever seen! This year it'll be Vincent and Angela! I expected more from Vincent with his experience and Angela has been real lucky! After the 1st couple weeks, she's on borrowed time!

    What fascinates me about Jeffery is his criticisms which are so seldom backed up in the end! I still have a very vivid memory of Jeff killing Kayne on his buying of that organza (sp) material for his pageant dress! Well we all know where that went in the "critical" column; and it wasn't acclaim! He really should worry about himself! Michael may save him though; done before with Santino last year! I still remember the Iman challenge when he mocked Santino saying something like,"I know there's tons of shit on this dress, but I'm going to show you anyway!" MK can be a scream; in more ways than one! Santino should have really "bitten it" that night with that GOLD monstrosity!

    ***"Robert, I love ya, but I don't even remember your dress. Come on you hot hunk of gayness, wake up!

    Oh, btw, I will shove some Harry Winstons up my nose if I can keep them afterwords. After a de-boogering nobody will know they were up my nose."***

    Robert is a doll isn't he?? He has the Clark Kent thing down pat! That jaw and chest just makes me melt; keep on the glasses! lol!!

    I have such a problem with the judging! Keith should've been gone for not even attempting to design for his dog, Vincent's garbage dress wasn't functional in any sense, and Angela should have bit the dust for that hooker outfit for her so called 'Director of Kids' ensemble! I love Robert, but he has ripped other designers for what they were doing and he's been in the bottom 3 twice! Katherine should have been spared except for the whining of "not going home!" Bradley was visiting another planet and shouldn't have even been picked even though it was genius what he threw together at the last minute for one challenge! .....

    .... Laura's clothes are timeless, but rather safe! Kayne will self destruct going over the top eventually! Alison had to go (Heidi jealous of her youth and looks while Uli was more like her mother)! Uli, Michael, and Jeffery will probably be the finalist with Jeff keeping the drama going! Nina's been fair for the most part! Bonnie's outfit was so '70's! My mom wore that I'm sure! Michael K.'s is just a jerk! He just can't help himself; sorta like Kayne! He will save Kayne once more I'm sure!

  74. ***They all had passports. Even Angela from OHIO. YOU DON'T GET THEM IN A DAY, so how much did they know beforehand with the so called security today seems impossible.***

    I said the same thing on the Designer Thread! I don't believe all those hillbillies had passports! It takes time unless you live in San Fran.! I wonder how they managed that! Anyway, Jeff deserved the win even though he's a snot, but Michael was a very close 2nd! They couldn't give Michael 3 wins this early on! lol! Laura's dress was nice, but the color just washed her out along with that fiery red hair! Poor Vincent looked like a homeless guy, but as always they saw his POV; yack! Uli hung on by a thread with that Moo Moo! She didn't make that thing for this episode; she took it out of her bags! I'd like to see her jet into Chgo in January wearing that get-up! The "hawk" would blow that thing over her head before you left the airport! Angela and Kayne should both have been put in front of a firing squad! How can they possibly think those outfits were suitable for travel?? I traveled a bit before I got on in years, and it didn't matter if I was a little uncomfortable! I wanted to look good and get some kind of respect from airline staff you don't get if you're wearing flip/flops! lol!

    The judges were hilarious, sparing no one's feeling! ROFLOL! Michael K. told Angela she looked a mess just standing there! The french judge told Kayne he looked ridiculous! How could he not know poor thing! If he comes up with one more outfit that is truly tasteless, he's gone next week! I thought he would go far until the last few challenges! He's all about glamour, and that can be deadly when you are trying to create something simple, unassuming, and crisp! We all can't wear neon lites on our backs Kayne!

    I didn't realize it until now but Angela was kicked with "nare" a hug except for Tim pushing her out the door! The woman is obviously screaming "I Am from another planet" if she really thought that outfit was travel appropriate!" Good riddance! If I have to hear her 'screeeechhhh' just one more time, I might go postal! The other designers were lucky they weren't rounded up for questioning at the airport causing such a disturbance with her big mouth!

    As I posted earlier, I'd rather look good and be uncomfortable than to be totally relaxed and emulating a homeless guy on the skids; Hey Vincent; NICE PAJAMAS! Kayne obviously went insane dealing with Angela for so long! Could he truly think that outfit was little more than a "neon sign" blinking on a dark rode; usually flashing vacancy===> (probably in his head)! Uli babe; you lucked out!! That Moo Moo was a big disappointment! I'd love to see you hit Chicago in January wearing that thing; BBRRrrr! Keep up the good work Michael, Laura, and Jeffery (tsk,tsk on that joy of Angie being auf'd)!

    I think most people have a problem grasping the concept of Couture! The item is handmade, detailed, and one of a kind! In my mind it's also something the common everyday woman wouldn't be wearing! Can you imagine Mom wearing Jeffery's dress getting on a train? No! This would be something Paris Hilton would wear meeting her girlfriends for lunch! The plaid really stood out! I thought he'd win just in front of Uli since most would think her dress more appropriate! The others just weren't finished or plain tacky! Remember Dynasty with Joan Collins and Linda Evans?? Now that was quite COUTURE! HOT!!

  75. ***"Jeffery literally can't open his mouth without shrieking to the world what a low-life he is. I've said it before, Bravo should have thrown him off the air just on principle when he said about Laura "I wish that bitch would have a stroke." They threw Keith off for breaking the rules, don't they have any rules against being a complete scumbag? I wonder if Angela will still think he's so awesome after she sees all the footage of him being a back-biting, misogynist pig. If he's makes it to the final 3, it will permanently damage the show."***

    I'm no fan of either Jeffery or Angela, but you don't think she brought some of this stuff on herself?? She was all over Kayne during the Tara challenge, she screwed up the sewing machines a few times without fixing them, she just about encouraged her mother to bad-mouth the dress being made for her! I personally couldn't take the shrieking every time something exciting happened! Control yourself girl; you're supposed to be an adult! I still hear her now when she won the Macy's challenge! My hands are shaking! lol!

    Sabotage?? lol!! I wonder how these people can even snipe at one another with cameras on them 24/7! On Top Chef Tiffani was thought to be sabotaging people; several times you could hear people complaining about "who changed the heat settings on my oven??" With her bulk she could hide what she did if it happened! lol!! She was a true villain like Angela! Jeffery just has little restraint! He's not conniving; just a jerk! I believe Angela was truly trying to get Jeff kicked! Some like Laura would have loved him gone like Keith, but she seems to be genuinely pleased when someone like Michael wins a challenge! Kayne and Jeff really twist and turn with forced grins if they don't take the day! Fairly sad really! Uli better show something new in the coming challenges or she'll be as gone as Robert! He had a couple good designs, but he was hammered for being boring! I'M yawning Uli!

    I'm not trying to start a fight or anything really, but I'm so tired of people being an apologist for people who live in their own little world and dump on everyone else! Too many times Santino was deluding himself with how great he was actually throwing some abominations down the catwalk falling apart, dripping with glue, and not even functional! MK termed it right when he uses the term "vulgar!" Santino's clothes and attitude were vulgar! At Fashion Week he couldn't restrain himself throwing out profanity describing his mom; "She's the Shits!" What a PIG!! Jeffery is almost as bad! He can't help pumping himself up as well, deluding himself up to the end when he barely survived another challenge! What a jerk!

    Don't cry for Keith! He should have known well ahead of time what would happen and how he would be perceived! Like most people, even going thru humiliation to the extreme, it's all worth it for the exposure! He will land on his feet I'm sure since he does have real talent! No one will actually believe anything he says, but how many times have people put themselves in this position just to get on tv?? Just look at shows like Jerry Springer, Cheaters, Taxicab Confessions, and other reality shows! The most personal aspects of their lives are thrown out there for all to see and they all sign those releases giving production staffers the go-ahead! No matter how angry and humiliated Keith may have seen, in his mind it was well worth it!

  76. ***Not so much in the case of Keith who seems intelligent if possessed of a HUGE blind spot, but don't you think that some reality show and bottom feeder talk show guests don't have the ability to act in their own best interests? And some of them drag their children along for a little psychological abuse as well. I think that a law should be passed requiring the producers of these shows to prove that their guests are competent to sign a waiver. The guests should have to pass a basic intelligence test!***

    Oh come on! Every challenge had Jeffery bad mouthing someone's effort! He was awful to Laura, ripped Kayne, Vincent, and Keith! He had nothing good to say about Angela, but that was definitely understandable! I loved it when he and Robert would question other people's work then find themselves at the bottom of those challenges! Talk about Karma! Let's not have short memories! The shows are rerun too much to get away with that!

    ***Read what I wrote. Jeffrey only talks bad in his close-up interviews (he talks behind their back) he hardly ever discusses someone in front of the other contestants, unlike Laura who only addresses the whole group or the person she is criticizing.***

    I read it and knew it! So what! It was rude and unnecessary so many times; especially when he was wrong! He hated Kayne's gown for Tara Conner! He didn't eat his words then or ever! He had to know his cattiness would get back to the other designers whether it was to their faces or behind the scenes in the close-up interviews! He's a jerk regardless! Pls stop trying to defend him! I can point out every instance where it was undeserved!

    I'm sure Jeffery's collection will be shown! Laura had the same concerns as Uli and Michael! She was just ballsy enough to express them unlike Uli who just sat back and forced all this conflict! Kayne did the same thing with the Keith controversy! He had to talk with everyone else 1st before actually confronting Keith! It's not easy to accuse someone of something like this with no proof, but she must have a reason! Are you telling me no one ever cheats? I can still hear Keith saying "it's ok to cheat a little because he thought he was right!" You can rationalize anything in your own mind! If Jeffery did do this, he can tell himself he did nothing wrong even though Laura may have a legitimate concern! This is a big deal! People are people!

    Tim really should stay out of this concerning the designs! How many times has he been wrong even when it's obvious he prodded the judges in a certain direction?? People who talk about the integrity of something like he does, has to be feeling guilty of something! How many time are people "auf'd" unjustly while others move on in the competition who you just have to open your mouth gaping, "HUH?" I still think Alison should have gone a lot further! Heidi may have felt a little threatened! ...These 4 will do I guess! I'm pulling for Michael who seems to be on the best even keel! Jeffery may pull it out though! Uli is just a one-noter if people think Laura is also! Heidi already said she would wear every outfit Laura put out, but ragged on her so! Looking forward to next week! I wonder what Jeffery was balling about?? Playing the victim is him especially after he wished a stroke on Laura! The SOD!

  77. Everything Laura created was commercial and could be sold tomorrow in Lloyd & Taylor, Norstoms, or other high fashion outlet! Jeffery is creative, but I can't see his stuff making the mainstream overnight! It's a little over the top most of the time even though I loved 2 or 3 of his creations like the Coutour gown (different but unfinished) and his own high-flying effort!

    Again I have to agree! Jeffrey should have pretended to be a little busy while others are frantically trying to finish their collections! It looks pretty bad to me knowing how many people work for him and with that huge working space! I hate a lot of tattoos, and corn-rolls, or other braiding of the hair! Like you I think it's gross; you just don't look clean! I couldn't hug him for money!! I'm surprised most do on the show except they feel it's necessary for the cameras! If you look greasy, I put my hands up!

    ***I totally agree that Jeffrey should not have won. I think perhaps the judges were trying to help him out since he's a 'former drug addict'. Maybe send a message? But still it's unfair to the others who were all better than he was. I won't be watching anymore. What's the point if anyone can win whether their designs are good or not.

    It seems as if the judges or someone wanted Jeffrey to win. He went over budget. He failed the challenge on that alone. As for him being a former drug addict...SO WHAT. I've known others who have been there, pulled themselves up, started their own businesses, and not treated people so rudely. He uses that as an excuse to do so.***

    I have to agree with the masses! This really sucks for the 3rd year in a row! I'm no fan favorite of Uli's, but her collection was the most beautiful; HANDS DOWN! Jeffery broke rules, benefited from it, then won this competition even though I believe his work was disjointed and tacky! A couple of pieces were passable, but under no conceivable way can anyone possibly think he was deserving! I love Laura, and her clothes were the most elegant and classy (as she is), but they can only be worn once! You get more out of something more plain or black! How do you clean something with feathers and beads without ruining it? It will be hard to come back for the next season, but I'm hooked even though the judging is so "whacked!" Good luck having your kid Laura!! Get bent Mr. Rock & Roll!" You and your clothes SUCK!

  78. ***I agree, Jeffrey's clothes DO make even the models look large. He puts the waist too high up, so then the dresses flare out and leave no shape - or something. I like what he does, in theory, but I would never wear least not his dresses.***

    I noticed that too! He's such a hypocrite as well! I can still hear him say, "Fuck; another high waisted dress" when commenting on one of Laura's design! What a jerk! He was lucky to even make Fashion Week with that milk maid outfit he created! Look in the mirror sometimes when you disparage other's creativity ya TOAD!

    ***YES! Jeffrey deserved to win!

    This is not a popularity contest - - or a pretty contest - - or an elegant contest. This is a best innovative with a future design contest. And that is Jeffrey. It means nothing that you hate him.

    EXACTLY! I can't believe how many people are so narrow-minded and thinking about this on a tv show level. This is serious business! Fashion design is not about who we like but where fashion is going and what's going to take it there!***

    I don't know how you can say this! They had to scrounge up someone to say they liked Jeffery's collection! Most loved Uli and Laura with an honorable mention of Michael! No way should that clown have taken this competition! Yuck!

    ***I agree Jay, but they only show us clips they want to show us. So we don't really know what was said about Jeff's collection. I think Betsy Johnson says what Jeff is trying to say much better. Jeff lost IMO because he didn't follow the rules, he went over budget.***

  79. ***... and another thing... Jeffrey's crap looked like a Candy land board game threw up on the runway. All those red & white polka dot and green & white stripe unflattering Rock Star, Madonna from the 80's, styles. I though Heidi had better taste then to judge Jeffrey's line the winner. But, I bet she wouldn't be caught dead wearing any of his clothing line... ...Your demographics of all viewers and consumers are not Mary Kate and Ashley Olson. Grow up and I'll start watching again when you do.***

    So true!! Uli and Laura's collections looked RICH! The judges made a comment that L's designs looked like a $30,000 line; I thought more like the full $100,000! I liked some of Michael's clothes, but something about them looked cheap! Uli's stuff was great and she should have won! In no conceivable level of consciousness could anyone not on drugs find Jeff's crap innovative and by far the best of these very talented designers! The fix had to be "IN!" Just pathetic! How dumb do these people think we are??

    When I hear Tim Gunn constantly invoking the "integrity card," I think back to that Twit; W!! He promised so much about being compassionate, a uniter not a divider, and that Iraq would be a cakewalk! LIAR, LIAR, pants on fire! He can't honestly believe in any religion or he'd know HELL is waiting for him! He turned this country upside down; and for what?? Good thing he should be a LAME DUCK along with his enablers of the Republican party! VOTE 11/7 for a new start!

    ***LOL! - now that Jeff's got $100 grand, I hope he'll BURN those damned bike shorts! He didn't look hip or artistic - just a ridiculous 36-year-old man trying to look like a grad student. He looked like an Oompa Loompa reject.***

    Speaking of what a designer looks like, what is the deal with most of them?? So often these people look like they're homeless! Maybe they think their clothes will look hotter if they look like BUMS! Richard Tyler should have been ashamed of the way he appeared a few weeks ago; greasy, unshaven, wrinkled! Yuck!! All the designers except Laura dressed like they were going to a picnic in the park instead of a fashion show! Have they never heard of a suit?? It really ticks me off when I see that! How credible are they in the world of designs when they can't even get themselves together??

    ***Doesn't this look similar to Kara's kimono dress?

  80. Watched quite a bit of Season 1! Like Top Design in it's 1st year, it started out kinda slow, production values weren't up to par, and you had the usual villain! As usual they keep saving someone who should have been auf'd weeks before! I still don't and can't believe Wendy made it to the final! She was sad and pathetic to the last; style was so OLD!! What is wrong with these judges?? A consistent designer who slips up once is "castrated," but they let someone very mediocre go on and on and on until they "have to" Nix them!! Kara Saun was robbed even though she slipped up a bit at the show!! The shoe thing could have been avoided and the dresses didn't need to be tripping up her models! I felt so badly for Austin Scarlet!! He blew it when he just didn't listen to the final challenge! He loves couture and just can't help but make everything a bit too glam and costumey! It was the Grammy's, not Oscar's babe!

    Is Jay actually working?? Even Nick gets more exposure! I see his name referenced, but not from really doing a show! Season 2 was much better, but how did the villain, Santino make it with all his BS crapola?? Daniel V. should have won, but I wasn't unhappy for Chloe! Season 3 was very frustrating with idiotic challenges! How could they choose Jeffery over anyone?? Keith should not have have gone anywhere with his rotten attitude about rules! I could have been satisfied with Uli, but I thought all of Laura's creations were a cut above and quite stylish! No accounting for taste huh?? lol!!

    ***During it's run, I did not like Wendy, not one bit, but after watching the reruns about a thousand times, I actually began to feel sorry for her. Everyone made her out to be this huge, evil person when all she did was criticize Austin (which he kinda deserved) and Kevin (which he deserved) and in the end I thought it was hilarious when 'Miss Perfect' ended up being the "cheater" and Wendy ended up doing exactly as she was supposed to do.

    And the judges did ask her opinion of them, so it wasn't like she just blurted it out of nowhere. I'd much rather hear the truth then to find out some bozo has been talking shit behind my back. The gang/mob mentality takes over on all of these shows. There always has to be someone who everyone hates. I think it happened to be Wendy because of her age... I dunno!

    My point exactly. It wasn't as if she cornered Nina and Heidi in the break room and said, "Psst, yeah, Austin, yeah, he's a really horrible leader, oh and Kevin too, yeah, I'm sooooooo gonna try and get them knocked off in my evil attempts to further myself in an already catty fashion world."

    I mean the way Kara Saun treated Wendy towards the end was just mind blowing because at the end, Wendy had seen herself on tv and tried to actually change for the better, while Kara just got a hell of a lot worse.

    Wendy, Tiffani, Stephen, Keith, or Sam ...mobs out for blood!***

  81. ***SANTINO was and still is the best designer and personality I've seen on PR, EVER. Santino's collection was beautiful. I also loved Jeffrey of Season 3; his designs were fantastic; I'm glad he won. The guy that got kicked off in Season 3 for having a book was an amazingly talented designer. I was sorry he got kicked off.***

    Huh?? We are talking about the same designers right? lol!! Santino was spared more than a few times! What can you say about the monstrosities he created: his plant dress, his Arabian number with gold palates for Iman, and the jumpsuit from Hell for Kara that was falling apart before she even stepped onto the catwalk?? Tim Gunn would have no idea how ill-fitting his tops were for Fashion Week so that point is moot well! Keith was ok, but delusional at the same time! How he survived without producing an outfit for his dog is still beyond me! He may have been creative, but had little idea how to sew letting Jeffery and Alison do all his work for the Banana Republic challenge! Jeffery was another designer who barely survived a few times! If it weren't for Robert throwing out so many bad outfits, he would have been canned for that tent he made for Angela's mom! I am offended he even was allowed to participate in FW since it appears he had a ton of help with his collection; just look at his workroom with plenty of stations for other designers to lend more than a little hand! I could go on, but enough of this rant! lol!! Here's hoping Season 4 is even better!

    They're playing Season 1 today for some reason! Hard to watch since it was a new show! They cleaned it up quite a bit, but you had the same scandals going on! You had the usual suspicion of sabotage, a psycho model, a crazy, but talented designer who makes a mistake and is gone, then of course the obligatory dismissal of a designer who's very pretty and blond; Heidi can't have that! You can say Jay is innovative and talented, but no way should he have won! Austin was just too couture, Kara Sean just didn't stay within the rules, and Wendy was the least talented designer there! She shouldn't have made it past the 1st 3 weeks! Oh well, we're being entertained so they must be doing something right by sucking us in every season! See ya'll tomorrow for the next and continuing episode of Top Chef!

    Season 2 played today into the final! I'm surprised no one had anything to say! As usual I was put off by Santino! How did he make it with those tacky, unwearable, and just plain bad designs?? No doubt he thinks outside the box, but if it's falling off your body in tatters, what are you supposed to say? lol!! Poor Kara will probably never believe she was auf'd before Santino! Believe it babe; that black rag was just awful!! Poor Daniel; for the final he really didn't have a hit besides his 13th piece which Nick helped with if I remember correctly! I missed that part surfin' channels and the net! I would have loved seeing and hearing Chloe's exasperation with "Miss Diana; she's killin' me!" lol!! She did a good job on that 13th piece though; the BABY DOLL! Santino didn't have a chance with his designs so ill-fitting in the tops!

  82. S3 running today! I really loved this group! Many were very talented, but the bad ones were very bad! How did cookie cutter designers like Vincent, Angela, Stacey, Bradley, and Bonnie make it to the show? Others were average, but a few didn't even know how to sew! Kayne was over the top, but he was amazing at times! His Marilyn Monroe gown was classic! I loved Robert, but had nothing that was original and memorable! I think I just wanted into his pants! lol! I thought he was so cute! Laura was great and I have no idea why Jeff had such a problem with her! He would look at her efforts and just exhale, "another high-waisted skirt!" 'Why do you care idiot? You should be worrying about those tacky outfits you were making! You were lucky to make the final, then win! Talk about an injustice!'

    Michael was very consistent all season, but dropped the ball at Fashion Week! His efforts were just a little weak! Uli was good, but also a one-note designer! All her stuff looked like you should be walking along the beach! She still should have won over Jeff! Too bad Keith got caught cheating! He looked like a druggie most of the time looking so tired, but he was quite sexy! He should have been auf'd when he didn't create an outfit for his dog! I still can't believe they kicked Katherine instead just because of a bad hem! That was tragic losing Milan especially since he has gone on to bigger and better things than this show! "Well done babe!" Loved his accent! I think I hit on everybody! How did you guys like seeing Season 3 all over again?

    ***Laura is a low life creep. Really, the worst kind of person. Someone does better work, or works harder on their collection and her warped reasoning is that that the person must have cheated. Instead of making this accusation to the person, Jeffery, she goes behind his back to inform the producers. A case study in how to behave with integrity and character. Abhorrent and disgusting.***

    And what good would that have done? He would have denied everything! What choice did she have? All the designers felt the same way; Laura was the only one with enough guts to call him on it! I would have been suspicious with that workroom and access to so many personal at his business! Are you telling me you wouldn't have thought the same thing? WAKE UP and smell the cleaning solution!

    ***I love these reunion shows. It always makes me laugh when someone gets upset at how they are portrayed. I think Keith, Jeffrey, and a few others, while not portrayed exactly as they are, it was a little too close for comfort!***

    Keith didn't have a leg to stand on; using books and then leaving for production for a few hours! Jeff and Vincent should have been brought to task more! Jeff was lucky to make it to the final much less win the season, but Vincent truly was delusional as Laura noted! He just has such a high opinion of his abilities and ragging on the amateurs he had to compete against was so funny! I hated Casey winning fan favorite on TC3, especially after they showed her to be the black widow of the show! Time and time again when she would get close to another chef, they were auf'd in short order! lol!

  83. ***Uli dressed Kayne's mom, not Michael's, although the two ladies had similar builds. Kayne dressed Michael's mom and was—I thought—unfairly criticized for being too "matchy-matchy," although Michael's mom clearly loved the outfit, it fit her beautifully, and she rocked it down the runway.***

    You can't take the judge's criticism too seriously! I think a little personal baggage is being toted during that process! Too often I feel they are saving someone or unfairly critiquing a designer when you hear them and you say "what the Hell are you talking about!" MK 'MOTB' comment is so overdone, and you know Nina is going to be merciless towards some designers before the judging is to take place! Like other shows like TC, TD, etc, I think judging should be blind; the judges shouldn't know who created what at 1st! That would eliminate some of the banter, but how usefull is it when they ask "what were you thinking when you did this?" What difference does that make, either you like it or you don't!

    ***Enough with the model drama/trauma. Why not before the season starts allow designers and models to meet and each have a part in choosing who they want to work with, ...? -- would save a lot of time and unnecessary tension.

    I for one dislike the disingenuousness of forcing designers after group projects to choose who they would eliminate on their team. Everyone is on edge already and IMO, it causes pointless damage to psyches, and as a result, only further exhausts and depletes the designers' creative energies. Yes, we all have to make tough decisions in the real world. But the way the question is set up and handled all-around is cruel. Point: In Season 2, Daniel Franco is praised for refusing to out either of his colleagues, while Santino is castigated and dumped on for attempting to answer the cruel question honestly. ...***

    These might be great suggestions, but they "aren't" hearing it! They love the drama created by designers back-stabbing one another! That's just an added bonus if it really gets "UGLY!" Ugly is ratting each other out with effort or lackthereof with a teammate (Wendy), screwing each other out of the best model (ULI vs Michael,S3 & Zulema vs Nick,S2), & egomania out of control (Santino & Keith)! I hope they get the hint or they'll run people off like they do on TC!

  84. ***I think last season was the epitome of too much drama. I mean it kind of sucked the fun out of it to see the designers treat each other so horribly or watch them sit by and watch others treat each other that way. ...It just seemed that all the challenges last year were overshadowed by the personal junk going on! ...***

    ***Yes, I agree that S3 was pretty bad as far as drama went- and talent, too for that matter. Uli made the same dress every week. Laura made the same high waisted/plunging V neck whatever every week. Angela with those butt-ugly flurshons? Vincent and his horrendous pieces of crap? Bradley? BRADLEY?? How this guy made it past the quarter finals is beyond me.

    As for the drama, I guess tension on the set makes for good ratings. Bravo can keep the drama if that's their selling point as long as they have the talented designers to back it up.

    I loved S3; especially Michael, who rightfully won the fan favorite award. I also loved Malan, Katherine, Bonnie and Alison. It was a shame that they got booted so soon, especially in favor of keeping Vincent, Angela, & Bradley. Costa la vie.

    What I didn't like about S3 was its predictable sequence of winners & losers. Every even week a female would win and a male would have to pack his belongings. Reverse that for the odd weeks. I knew Keith was safe in the doggie challenge because it was a female's week to lose. Same with week #2; Malan was in trouble and Angela was safe. C'mon, Bravo! Be fair this season!***

    ITA with everything you mentioned! Something else is going on behind the scenes we may never find out about! Vincent and Angela were saved over and over again while poor little ALISON was auf'd after showing she had real talent! I mentioned earlier as a joke that HEIDI probably told production to "get rid of her!" She can't be shown up like that on camera by some little chippy so pretty! Same thing happened to Alexandra in S2! Both are stunning women with huge talent and potential!

  85. ***If I'm remembering correctly, the main way that Jeffrey(S3) stayed within budget at the end was by not using those wigs that he brought with him to FW, in addition to the shorts.***

    Sounds right! My problem with S3 is "HOW DID HE EVEN MAKE IT TO THE FINAL?" Like Santino, they rag him all season about being a one-note or being tasteless, but he makes it thru with that Milk Maid outfit, after skating on the hooker outfit he made in the Black & White challenge! These judges have lost all credibility when people like Santino, the most classic of one-noters in ULI, Jeffery, and most of all Jay who didn't win anything until the final make it thru! Some designers were consistently good and they get all the praise during the season, but in the end they are trashed for not 'thinking outside the box!' (i.e. Daniel V, Laura, Austin, and Michael)

    ***I really liked Jay's funky aesthetic throughout S1, and I felt vindicated when he won the season despite never having won an episode's challenge. Santino? I was a fan early on, but his attitude soured me--that doesn't mean I don't think his designs were worthy, though. It's kind of the same with Jeffrey ... I didn't care for his attitude AT ALL, but I thought his aesthetic was fantastic--edgy, playful, and with just the right balances between real and imagined, rock and reality, juvenile and mature. It's just all so relative, y'know?

    Robert was the stud muffin of S1, always running around in his black underwear or on one memorable occasion, nothing.***

    Don't forget the half naked workouts on the floor with that roller-wheel device! Keith in S3 had a sexiness, but looked a bit thin and drugged out! My favorite babe was Robert in S3! His designs stunk, but he was my sexy "Clark Kent!" He was so cute to me! I did like Daniel V. in S2, but was shocked by his behavior towards the end! He cut Chloe on that last challenge when Heidi asked who should go to Fashion Week! All 'club' Santino over the head for his lack of taste and how unfinished his work was, but everyone thought he should go! WHY?? You had a couple handsome BOYS this season, but when you see and hear them up close, it's a big turn-off! Rami and Jack were the babes of S4!! Jack was great, but Rami's berating Sweet-P because she wasn't working to his standards was so over the top DIVA! "Get a grip babe, you just barely made it with all that draping!"

  86. ***I don't understand how Jack could trace the pattern for the pants. Meanwhile that guy from the prior season got kicked off for just having books of patterns as inspiration and not directly using them. It does not seem fair at all to me.***

    Vincent got away with doing the exact same thing for the "jet setter" challenge! He took his pants off right in the workroom and traced the pattern! He should have been axed for those pajamas he made for the Paris trip! If Angela hadn't been even worse with her "Moonbeam" outfit, he would have been auf'd and justifiably so! Kayne wasn't much better with the glitter shirt! As I said, men's wear is tough; especially if a woman is trying to make it (that would include Kayne (no offense)), lol

    Close, but ticked at TC just as much! They do the same thing; set the designers up to fail! Everyone knows men's wear design is 10 times harder than women's! Women will wear just about anything if it's called fashion forward! Men have not evolved much more than to wear business casual at work on friday! Since I was a kid, Europe has been pushing the men's skirt! It ain't happenin' in this country! You have some gay men wearing a kilt here and there to IML, but overall we're still pulling on styles from years gone by! You can dress it up all you want with giving some guys the new title of Metro sexual, you're still wearing shirts and slacks; very basic, with little color or texture differences! I'm surprised more than one person wasn't axed! Those outfits were horrendously bad! Poor designers!

    ***I loved this episode. They need to include a good men's wear challenge in each season.***

    I said it earlier that men's wear is tough! It has to be simple, but it's hard to design something that's original and stylish at the same time for men! Just throw some shoulder pads in a piece of cloth and call it fashion forward and women will wear it! Men are very picky and don't like innovation! The most we've expanded our ideas about fashion is wearing business casual to work! Europe for 20+ years has been pushing a men's skirt or kilt, but I've only seen them sparingly at Gay events like IML here in Chgo!

    It's just been a marathon for PR! Watched a little of Season 2 and I still can't believe these tasteless hacks kept letting Santino skate thru! To the last idiots like Nina professed that he was meant for fashion! Time and time again he sent gaudy, tacky, and unfinished work down the runway! In the meantime, real talented designers like Daniel and Chloe had to scrap for any kind of approval in comparison! They actually won more than one challenge and few items were what I would consider bad; Daniel's outfit for Chloe wasn't the best, but it was finished unlike Santino's jumpsuit for Kara! That thing was glued and falling apart and there he was bullying her to say how much she liked it! What a goof! She was just as bad by letting him get away with it during the judging! They all thought he should have been auf'd, even talking about him behind his back, but there she stood silent, letting him make it her fault the sleeve was falling off! IDIOT BITCH!

  87. ***...The disasters began to happen at the lingerie challenge. The judges saw something in Santino that kept him there. They believed in him. It's good enough for me. As much as I adore the guy, I still think Daniel V. should have won.

    The reason Project Runway used to be my favorite show was because it was a fair and true competition. By sending Chris home instead of Ricky the show has totally sold out to petty reality tv drama. Just because Ricky cries every show and fought with Victoria doesn't mean we, as the audience, want to see him. He has consistently had the worst designs and really deserved to go. I'm so disappointed in the new season.***

    I had no doubt between the 2 of them, Ricky wasn't goin' anywhere! lol!! He makes for good tv! We've seen it before; someone truly lacking and made horrible mistakes, but squeaks thru for quite a while! Santino was the worst offender by throwing costumes down the runway, but kept on surviving!

    ***You are both so right! Ricky is awful and should have been gone two challenges ago. He does make for good TV, but rather makes me sick every time I see the "comments (or should I say tears)" with him, I just get nauseous. He is not good TV nor a good designer. Go home already...

    HEY, I don't know if this has been posted before, but has anyone noticed that the models, who have always appeared in black slips and barefoot, are wearing high heels this season?***

    Maybe it's my imagination, but these models appear to be the worst! Maybe they were being tested for a model show; they have a long way to go! lol!! They're just a bit gawky and uncoordinated!

  88. ***I had no idea that Jack did nudes. I can't imagine they would throw him off the show for that. ...Know what? I have a feeling they might bring back Chris since Jack's leaving next week and Chris is the last eliminated. ...Haha.. Jay- I have this thought from the get go. The are way like hunched over & walk in a totally weird manner. This is the first season in which I've even noticed the models, and not in a good way. The models should be there simply to show off the clothes, not to show off the fact that they've shunned the whole scoliosis brace in high school.***

    Maybe it's BS! I'm hoping this is all speculation and Jack will continue on! ...I hadn't heard that, but I can imagine him doing nudes! He perfectly fits a collection of posters I own by Victor Screbneski and Ansel Adams! Perfect specimens like Jack hitting the waves, in other landscapes; and of course the shadowy blk/wht Chgo Int'l Film Festival posters by VS!

    I watched this episode three times now! Did I hear Ricky making a comment of 'true colors' when his model was ripped off? Am I right in thinking he did the same thing 2 challenges ago? He must be a Republican too! They just can't help themselves either!

    ***I don't think the drama for next week is Jack getting kicked off -- particularly not due to AIDS. On the Bravo site, they show new gossip that Jack and Dale from Top Chef are dating. If Jack wasn't healthy or had left in disgrace, I don't think they would be highlighting it like they are. I bet he has news or saw something regarding another designer or model.

    ITA - on Jack and Ricky bitching about his model being taken away!***

    I said it yesterday like everyone else here, "Ricky ain't goin' anywhere!" They do this every season; holding onto some "scrub" for as long as possible to make it easy to auf them later down the line! He's doomed unless he really pulls it together! He knows what he' doing, he's just not executing properly! Victorya fooled me big time! I thought she was about as animated as her dress form; she took over last nite to Ricky's amazement and consternation! She turned into Vera Wang in one fell swoop! lol! Poor Donna Karan; she looked awful! I haven't seen her in years; she has money, get some work done babe! You ain't Barbra Streisand; she can get away with that bulbous clown nose!

  89. ***Victorya being a Wendy... hmm.....***

    Victorya and Wendy? A comparison? Nyah! Victorya might be a lot of things, but she's not a talentless HACK! Wendy's an old bag, stuck in the 50's and had no business making the final! Saw her once on Bravo's celebrity poker last year, and that was it; hopefully the last time we have to see her! Victorya has an eye, makes a decision, and has some real talent! No comparison can be made between those 2!

    ***I agree.. that no comparison can be made of them as designers! I think that either Victorya's or Chris's dress should have won the first challenge, though I think her "Bitten" dress looked maternity.

    I was referring to the behaviour that seems like passive aggressiveness. She was setting up Ricky the way Wendy Pepper set up Austin in the team challenge in Season One. It could be youth and insecurity, but it could also be that blaming others for her own folly is her modus operandi.

    I just thought the walk-off with Zulema was a bit over the top. But what I really hated was that Tim said Rachael was like an elongated marshmallow. Sometimes he can be very harsh, for all the great manners and cool words (like verklempt) that he uses.

    I agree that it sounded harsh. I think that he was talking as an artist about a form, and not as a human about a human.***

    That's why I've never been a big fan of Tim's! He can be brutal with criticism and to me a rather cold fish! Merciless should be his middle name! lol! I really don't watch his other show, but from what I can tell with a quick look, he brings these women to tears at times; not always happy ones! When he trashes their wardrobe, then goes for the jugular about their underwear, I gues